Re:‘Mutual aid’ is a radical ideal. Some live its communal s...
by kerkeslager on Sunday February 12, 2023 @02:36PM
(#34766069)
> Major cities spend 100s of millions per year each on homelessness (LA is $500m-1B iirc, depending on how you attribute), for combined spending of a few B per year, and they cannot even make a dent.
The solution to homelessness is homes. If you aren't spending money giving homeless people homes--not shelters, homes--you're not spending anything on homelessness. You're spending money on compassion theater to make people feel better.
Which cities are spending money on giving homeless people homes?
> As much as I would be receptive to an argument that this is because most public employees are malicious, incompetent grifters,
That's not what I said at all. On the contrary, I think that most public employees are doing the best they can to do as much good as they can within a system that isn't designed to fix homelessness.
> (1) I doubt Musk/etc. could do even an order of magnitude better, especially in the real world, with real-world employees and regulations, (2) even if Musk himself "could" somehow be much more efficient, mutual assistance schemes that would expropriate and use his wealthwould attract, and would be taken over by, the same kinds of structures - public sector unions, etc., as they were pretty much everywhere anything like this has been attempted.
Again, actual attempts to address homelessness have never been attempted on any scale, because real estate owners, NIMBYs, and people who oppose any public assistance have blocked it at every turn.
The solution to homelessness is homes. If you aren't spending money giving homeless people homes--not shelters, homes--you're not spending anything on homelessness. You're spending money on compassion theater to make people feel better.
Which cities are spending money on giving homeless people homes?
> As much as I would be receptive to an argument that this is because most public employees are malicious, incompetent grifters,
That's not what I said at all. On the contrary, I think that most public employees are doing the best they can to do as much good as they can within a system that isn't designed to fix homelessness.
> (1) I doubt Musk/etc. could do even an order of magnitude better, especially in the real world, with real-world employees and regulations, (2) even if Musk himself "could" somehow be much more efficient, mutual assistance schemes that would expropriate and use his wealthwould attract, and would be taken over by, the same kinds of structures - public sector unions, etc., as they were pretty much everywhere anything like this has been attempted.
Again, actual attempts to address homelessness have never been attempted on any scale, because real estate owners, NIMBYs, and people who oppose any public assistance have blocked it at every turn.