Re:Japan Adopts Plan to Make Maximum Use of Nuclear Power
by emodendroket on Sunday February 12, 2023 @03:14AM
(#34760960)
Do you think we evolved fear by accident? If I were handling a venomous snake I'd be scared to be bit and rightly so. There's no reason to be proud of being heedless of risk.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Japan Adopts Plan to Make Maximum Use of Nuclear Power
by snovv_crash on Sunday February 12, 2023 @03:50AM
(#34761171)
And what if it was a non-venomous snake, and all the experts tell you it is a non-venomous snake, and it is literally safer than a pet dog. Would you still be scared of handling it because of a pathological fear of snakes? In what way is that adaptive and helpful in a modern era of scientific knowledge?
Re:Japan Adopts Plan to Make Maximum Use of Nuclear Power
by emodendroket on Sunday February 12, 2023 @04:03AM
(#34761259)
Well, the setup was you told me people should feel embarrassed to be scared whether or not they support nuclear power. If they accepted the premise you are setting up now — that it is utterly risk-free — why wouldn’t they support it?
Re:Japan Adopts Plan to Make Maximum Use of Nuclear Power
by simondotau on Sunday February 12, 2023 @05:36AM
(#34761760)
> the premise you are setting up now — that it is utterly risk-free
That is a fairly egregious misrepresentation of what they said.
Re:Japan Adopts Plan to Make Maximum Use of Nuclear Power
by emodendroket on Sunday February 12, 2023 @10:55AM
(#34763765)
How was I meant to interpret “a non-venomous snake, literally safer than a pet dog” as an analogy if it didn’t mean that nuclear power was extremely safe?
Re:Japan Adopts Plan to Make Maximum Use of Nuclear Power
by mpweiher on Sunday February 12, 2023 @01:45PM
(#34765548)
Nuclear power is "extremely safe. It is arguably the safest form of energy we have, unarguably one of the safest and unarguable the safest reliable form of energy.
But not "utterly risk free".