Re:Theory of Mind May Have Spontaneously Emerged in Large La...
by Retric on Saturday February 11, 2023 @06:13PM
(#34757432)
The problem with that assessment is it doesn’t actually account for novel inputs.
Consider how you would respond to my question posed here vs a language model. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34757366
Of course developers can always tack on edge cases, but ChatGPT can’t for example handle beating a novel MUD from the 80’s. This isn’t about diminishing it’s accomplishments, just pointing out why the creators aren’t hailing it as AGI.
This is a bit of extrapolation but I would say the reason why we’ve been unable to locate “consciousness” in the brain is because it’s the same thing. Relatively simple neurones, chained together, to create thought.
On a philosophical level: this doesn’t make any claims for idealism or materialism, “experience” could exist at a more fundamental level of reality than matter. But IMO that would mean that the LLM is “experiencing” as well.