News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:I had ChatGPT write a Decemberists song and recorded it by jug on Saturday February 11, 2023 @02:28PM (#34755453)
I find this interesting not from the perspective of LLMs but it seems to imply that human language being a prerequisite for self-awareness. Is that really so?
Re:I had ChatGPT write a Decemberists song and recorded it by Baeocystin on Saturday February 11, 2023 @03:00PM (#34755752)
It's a reasonable hypothesis. Being good at calculating 'What would happen next if {x}' is a reasonable working definition of baseline intelligence, and the capabilities of language allow for much longer chains of thought than what is possible from a purely reactive approach.

Entering the realm of Just My Opinion, I wouldn't be surprised at all if internal theory of mind is simply an emergent property of increasing next-token prediction capability. At a certain point, you hit a phase change, where intelligence loops back on itself to include its own operation as part of its predictions, and there you go- (some form) of self-awareness.

Re:I had ChatGPT write a Decemberists song and recorded it by bee_rider on Saturday February 11, 2023 @04:40PM (#34756660)
Do these test imply that a theory or mind requires human language any more so than a mirror test implies that self-awareness requires eyeballs?
Re:I had ChatGPT write a Decemberists song and recorded it by shagie on Saturday February 11, 2023 @07:41PM (#34758122)
Can we think without language? - https://mcgovern.mit.edu/2019/05/02/ask-the-brain-can-we-thi...

> Imagine a woman – let’s call her Sue. One day Sue gets a stroke that destroys large areas of brain tissue within her left hemisphere. As a result, she develops a condition known as global aphasia, meaning she can no longer produce or understand phrases and sentences. The question is: to what extent are Sue’s thinking abilities preserved?

> Many writers and philosophers have drawn a strong connection between language and thought. Oscar Wilde called language “the parent, and not the child, of thought.” Ludwig Wittgenstein claimed that “the limits of my language mean the limits of my world.” And Bertrand Russell stated that the role of language is “to make possible thoughts which could not exist without it.” Given this view, Sue should have irreparable damage to her cognitive abilities when she loses access to language. Do neuroscientists agree? Not quite.

The Language of Thought Hypothesis - https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/language-thought/ (which has a long history going back to Augustine)

---

If 23 year old me were here now and considering future life paths, I'd be sorely tempted to be looking at declaring/finishing a dual CS/philos major and going to grad school.