Re:Is Net Zero Dystopian, Imperialistic and Coercive?
by pavel_lishin on Saturday February 11, 2023 @10:50AM
(#34753359)
This is, pardon my language, fucking stupid.
> But isn’t this all about saving the planet and sacrifice for the next generations?
> No, the planet doesn’t need saving. This is an ordinary planet circling around an ordinary star among billions of stars, part of an ordinary galaxy among billions of galaxies. This planet has nothing to do with the flourishing of human civilization. It is the human endeavor, science, technology and knowledge that has made this place habitable and we can make any other similar planet habitable for us.
It is willfully contrarian and stupid to argue that we don't need to "save the planet" because the massive rocky body will maintain its orbit, when it's incredibly clear that the meaning is "keep it habitable for future civilizations".
And for a person who spends so much time worrying about what Net Zero means for developing nations, they're sure cavalier with the fact that we can "make any planet habitable", implying but not stating that we can do so for everyone, everywhere, without incurring any costs - in terms of dollars, or lives.
It's also a flat out wrong statement; we haven't made the Earth habitable in any meaningful sense, it started out that way, and we haven't even stepped foot on any other planet. The closest thing is a few dozen people camping out on the Moon for a few days, and several people in low-earth-orbit habitats that require constant resupply.
I don't know if Net Zero is dystopian, imperialistic or coercive, but I do know that this post is riddled with rhetorical nonsense and flat-out wrong statements.
> But isn’t this all about saving the planet and sacrifice for the next generations?
> No, the planet doesn’t need saving. This is an ordinary planet circling around an ordinary star among billions of stars, part of an ordinary galaxy among billions of galaxies. This planet has nothing to do with the flourishing of human civilization. It is the human endeavor, science, technology and knowledge that has made this place habitable and we can make any other similar planet habitable for us.
It is willfully contrarian and stupid to argue that we don't need to "save the planet" because the massive rocky body will maintain its orbit, when it's incredibly clear that the meaning is "keep it habitable for future civilizations".
And for a person who spends so much time worrying about what Net Zero means for developing nations, they're sure cavalier with the fact that we can "make any planet habitable", implying but not stating that we can do so for everyone, everywhere, without incurring any costs - in terms of dollars, or lives.
It's also a flat out wrong statement; we haven't made the Earth habitable in any meaningful sense, it started out that way, and we haven't even stepped foot on any other planet. The closest thing is a few dozen people camping out on the Moon for a few days, and several people in low-earth-orbit habitats that require constant resupply.
I don't know if Net Zero is dystopian, imperialistic or coercive, but I do know that this post is riddled with rhetorical nonsense and flat-out wrong statements.