Re:Bird.makeup: a Twitter to ActivityPub bridge
by smoldesu on Saturday February 11, 2023 @11:28AM
(#34753727)
> It is fediverse! It is supposed to be public and federated!
That's the bad assumption. Federation =! Public. If someone does something abhorrant/annoying/harmful on another instance, you should be able to disconnect from them. Just because an API exists doesn't entitle you to abuse it.
This sentence reminded me of another incident. Ben Boyter launched a service called Mastinator [0], like Mailinator, where you can create disposable fediverse accounts. The fantastic use of this is that you can anonymously follow anyone you want. However, it wasn't taken well by the people. A popular user tooted [1] something like this, and do check the entire conversation:
> A site called Mastinator (https://mastinator.com) has started aggregating and republishing toots without permission. It creates accounts with your handle and follows you to get your toots (e.g., @[email protected], which, just to make clear, is not me).
> @boyter You could, yes. But if you set up an account in my name on your instance, I would call you out for impersonating me and using my name/identity without permission.
They were angry that this service let you access their public posts without permission. It is fediverse! It is supposed to be public and federated! He also started getting hate from other people in the fedi, in many instances, started blocking the service. [2]
[0] - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34156395
[1] - https://mastodon.ar.al/@aral/109585159213960986
[2] - https://boyter.org/posts/mastinator-activitypub-breaking-ass...