Hottest take I've seen on here for a while. In a very specific, very limited set of mobile usecases, buttons may offer a more pleasant experience than a touchscreen. I only say that because there's usually exceptions to any statement, but I can't actually think of one.
Touchscreens didn't win because of some lazy sheep-like consumerism, they won because the product is superior. If Chat-GPT style models defeat traditional search engines it will be because the product is better, not because people are content with a response that "seems correct."
It’s a crap interface compared to others but it’s the best to do anything. That’s why it won.
When defining "better" you need to indicate the metrics you are using. LM's might be "better" when measured with certain metrics, but like most things are worse when measured using other metrics.
One is not superior to the other over all, but each is better at certain things. The difference is that more people will pay money to maximize their user experience scrolling through feeds and watching videos, compared to typing emails.
Touchscreens win when you need multiple interfaces in the same amount of space.
I still miss my landscape key board phones. The droid 4 still holds a special place in my head.
I can understand why some times you might just want a chat response to a question rather than a web search.
But I swear that if I even suspect Siri's response is influenced by advertising or endorses a product, I will take the homepod and punt it down the street.
Irony of this article, predicting end of Google, is that articles like this are going to be replaced by these summaries too.
Touchscreens are worse than buttons, it was a new paradigm to learn and the feedback of feeling a button, even small one, is better than not. Probably what forever doomed the Touch Bar.
Now for search, chat gbt will probably always be worse than a list of results you can get yourself for authenticity if you cared about truth.
That said… I don’t think people care about truth that much these days so a response that seems correct is probably good enough. Terrifying times we live in folks.