News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:ChatGPT lied to me and then tried to deny it by adventured on Wednesday February 08, 2023 @03:36PM (#34714638)
Lying only requires the action of the deceit. Intent is not required. It doesn't matter if you intended to lie (as to whether it's in fact a lie or not); if you lied, it's still a lie regardless of your intentions. If there is understanding of the deceit (such that the lie is intentional) then that applies a higher level of moral culpability to the intent, however understanding is not required to lie (you'd never reach the end of: how much exactly is required to be understood for it to be a lie - omnipotence).

Things like intent and understanding are to assess responsibility.

Re:ChatGPT lied to me and then tried to deny it by docdeek on Wednesday February 08, 2023 @03:44PM (#34714781)
I'm not sure I would agree.

My three year old is learning to count. If I ask him what comes after the number 15 and he replies 17, I don't think he has lied to me. He made an error. He thought it was the correct answer but it wasn't. I know he said something that is not true, but without any intent to deceive me, is it a lie? Is he a liar? I don't think so - the intent matters.