News for hackers. Stuff that matters.

A comment on Google's Live from Paris Event Private/Deleted Immediately. Parent comment

Re:Google's Live from Paris Event Private/Deleted Immediately by monknomo on Wednesday February 08, 2023 @11:36AM (#34710561)
just wondering aloud, but say like this eats google's lunch and search goes away. These chatbots provide answers, and footnotes. In a world like this, where the need is reduced to actually go to a website, what's the incentive for maintaining a website that no one visits? After a couple rounds of "adversarial training data evolution," that is, people optimizing their websites to get mentions by chatbots, will the bots really be better than google? After a couple routes of revenue improvements, will the chatbot responses remain good? And if folks quit maintaining websites, do the chatbots get a bit stuck in time from when their training data was last good?

I feel like there is something here, but I wonder if second order effects make it trickier than it appears atm

[ Parent | on HN ]
Re:Google's Live from Paris Event Private/Deleted Immediately by Raidion on Wednesday February 08, 2023 @11:58AM (#34710934)
It's the dying out of the "middle" of the value curve. You end up with a market that's dominated by cheap "good enough" products for casuals and "products built to last" for power users.

So if you have a low effort website that's factual and text based, you're going to get your lunch eaten by GPT, if you have a higher effort website (subscription gated with lots of multimedia content and user engagement) you'll be fine.

Think of all the blogspam recipe sites that are going to run into trouble when ChatGPT learns to cook well. Lots of text, little additional value, no community. There still will be America's Test Kitchen because people on the upper end of the value curve don't just want a recipe, they want pictures + video of that recipe being made and a place where they can ask questions and get answers.

[ Parent | on HN ]
Re:Google's Live from Paris Event Private/Deleted Immediately by ridgered4 on Wednesday February 08, 2023 @12:57PM (#34711968)
> In a world like this, where the need is reduced to actually go to a website, what's the incentive for maintaining a website that no one visits?

I guess to get the bots to tell your lies.

[ Parent | on HN ]