News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Commenting, community deterioration, and Hacker News by groggles on Monday January 16, 2012 @10:44AM (#3470990)
>These are examples of 'bad' comments

They weren't bad comments at all. The circle-the-wagons "we're better than this" reaction is worse.

While a death is usually a tragedy, made magnitudes worse when it's a child, the title of that post was absurd, and it was a giant elephant in the room that simply had to be rationally diffused. Like others I went into that story primarily to read how she was a programming prodigy.

Tragic death. Not a programming prodigy. The misrepresentation was noticed by all, and it will be a sad day when social convention means we all have to carry forward the lie lest we offend someone's sensibility about death.

Re:Commenting, community deterioration, and Hacker News by dctoedt on Monday January 16, 2012 @06:26PM (#3473081)
Upvoted - this [groggles' comment] hits the nail on the head.

PG, given that you gray-out comments that get torrentially downvoted, perhaps you could bold-face (or render in green?) those comments that get a certain number of upvotes, or perhaps those comments that exceed X% of the aggregate number of upvotes for the thread.