Re:Bill would ban the teaching of scientific theories in Mon...
by crazygringo on Tuesday February 07, 2023 @07:55PM
(#34702482)
I'm not defending it -- but it's because it's a federal government, not a centralized government.
One of the key tenets is therefore that governing is left to the states if there isn't a compelling reason that it needs to be done at a national level.
Things like national defense and regulating interstate commerce can only be done nationally, so they are.
But education is actually one of the classic examples in a federal system where it's hard to argue a compelling reason for nationalization. To the contrary, it's argued that if states are free to experiment then they can come up with better education standards and copy each other organically. But they can also tailor education to meet their local cultural values and history.
Of course, more and more things have become "nationalized" over the past century just because it's more efficient and less complicated. But wow do people argue about it.
One of the key tenets is therefore that governing is left to the states if there isn't a compelling reason that it needs to be done at a national level.
Things like national defense and regulating interstate commerce can only be done nationally, so they are.
But education is actually one of the classic examples in a federal system where it's hard to argue a compelling reason for nationalization. To the contrary, it's argued that if states are free to experiment then they can come up with better education standards and copy each other organically. But they can also tailor education to meet their local cultural values and history.
Of course, more and more things have become "nationalized" over the past century just because it's more efficient and less complicated. But wow do people argue about it.