Re:Tech's Elite Hates Labor
by hackerlight on Tuesday February 07, 2023 @06:25PM
(#34701463)
> The possibilities are endless... why attribute success to one single person?
I don't disagree, but this same critique can be applied to anyone, yet it disproportionately gets applied to CEOs. How can a SWE justify their $300k compensation? After all, the fact they hold that job can all be explained by circumstance, parenting, genes, being born in the right country, etc.
Also, in these discussions there's often a conflation between explaining why CEOs have the pay they do, and explaining whether it's subjectively fair under their moral system. Those are two separate questions. The people attempting the latter often play hide the ball, and attempt to give an incorrect explanation to the former in order to argue that their case for the latter is an objective case and not a subjective one.
Indeed. That's kind of my gut reaction to highly paid big tech employees asking for "fair" pay. Seems a bit "hypocritical"(?) to only consider fairness within the industry and not society as a whole.
On the other hand, you can also say that the board should be paid 100x because they somehow picked the right CEO.
But why stop there? Shouldn't the CEO's parents get a bonus for the upbringing of such a brilliant person? Or should the CEO's teachers get paid as well? The possibilities are endless... why attribute success to one single person?
PS: I'm not seriously saying this is what we should do. I'm just trying to illustrate how the concept of fairness looks a bit funny if you think hard about it.