> Given that “the market” seems to have settled on LC as the only measure of skill
That’s not true and I suspect you know it.
Success at LC + system design + behavioral interview earns one a position at the staff/principal level or below at west coast tech companies.
Above that level you need an industry rep and/or an inside champion to land the job.
It seems quite literally that LC performance is a major factor in the most lucrative market for software engineers in the world.
Given that “the market” seems to have settled on LC as the only measure of skill I don’t think it’s far fetched to imagine that a guild system could be better.