Re:We come to bury ChatGPT, not to praise it
by chii on Monday February 06, 2023 @10:54PM
(#34688559)
Yep. The same argument was put forward against chess engines - that they didn't really play chess! All they did was search all possibilities and spat out the "best" outcome based on some scoring system.
And yet, these engines have beaten the best humans.
The forms underneath intelligence, or thinking, doesn't matter. The outcome is what matters.
The point of the Turing test, to me, was that if a process responds in a logical way, you can’t really tell whether it is thinking or computing - and it doesn’t matter.