News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Programming prodigy passes away at 16 by jacquesm on Sunday January 15, 2012 @03:14PM (#3468102)
This thread and a the story make me equally sad.

The thread because this is one of the most hateful and ugly threads I've ever seen on HN. A thread like this would be literally unthinkable a year or more ago, and now I'm not even surprised it is here.

The story because it is about the death of a person that could easily be a role model for a large number of young children, but females especially in third world - and other - countries.

Those writing from their comfy first world lives that feel the need to point out how 'privileged' this girl was and belittle her achievements have to stop and think - excellent advice from elsewhere in this thread - before they continue to write.

The internet has a long memory. Being insensitive to the death of any child makes you look ugly, stupid and negative in ways that I find hard to describe.

Whatever your motivation, jealousy, a general misunderstanding of the station of women in many third world countries or any other thing that might have prompted you to write what you wrote here: Let me tell you straight from the heart that I think this girl was everything you in particular should aspire to be.

Smart, articulate, compassionate and gifted. The fact that she may or may not have been a member of a family of some standing in Pakistan does not diminish her achievements.

More often than not those that are born into positions of wealth or with other so called advantages squander their fortunes and end up with less than their parents left them with. That's an all too common story.

This girl took what little life she had and grasped it with both hands, then made the best of it. I hope that when my time comes I'll be able to say I did the same.

Re:Programming prodigy passes away at 16 by bitops on Sunday January 15, 2012 @10:46PM (#3469264)
> The thread because this is one of the most hateful and ugly threads I've ever seen on HN. A thread like this would be literally unthinkable a year or more ago, and now I'm not even surprised it is here.

I agree with you on this point a thousand times. What is going on with this community? In general I like HN, but there's a real trend brewing when it comes to gender-related articles. And it's not pretty.

HN regularly churns out some of the most biased, vitriolic and short-sighted commentary when it comes to women that I've ever seen in any online community.

Question is, what can we do to counteract it?

[EDIT: as expected, I'm being downvoted. Good riddance, HN.]

Re:Programming prodigy passes away at 16 by redthrowaway on Monday January 16, 2012 @03:02AM (#3469819)
>HN regularly churns out some of the most biased, vitriolic and short-sighted commentary when it comes to women that I've ever seen in any online community.

I really don't see that at all. There might be some implied sexism, and perhaps occasionally overt sexism, but it's nothing like what you see on other parts of the Internet. I've seldom read a top-rated comment on HN and thought, "wow, that's really sexist." Sure, they exist at the bottom of the page, but there isn't much we can do about that.

Do you have a discussion in mind that makes you feel that way? I'd like to see an example of what you consider "biased, vitriolic, and short-sighted commentary when it comes to women."

Re:Programming prodigy passes away at 16 by bermanoid on Monday January 16, 2012 @03:32AM (#3469883)
In general I like HN, but there's a real trend brewing when it comes to gender-related articles. And it's not pretty.

I didn't notice any gender-related comments on this article (I'm late to the party, so maybe I missed some that were higher up earlier), but HN does tend to be a place where people tend to post statements of disagreement far more often than they agree with whatever is posted. I'm certainly guilty of this myself on many (most?) occasions.

To some extent this is good and fosters a spirit of healthy debate, but in this case, it's out of place. This is an extremely sad event, and we don't need to be picking apart this girl's achievements while we should be mourning her passing, whatever her gender may be. Whether or not a Microsoft certification is a fantastic achievement at whatever age, this girl represents all the qualities that we should be encouraging in young people everywhere, and it's horrifying to see people try to diminish that.

It's always a tragedy when a 16 year old dies; it's even more upsetting when they were on such a promising trajectory. We should be sad about this without reservation, not questioning whether her path was provably remarkable enough to be worth talking about.

Re:Programming prodigy passes away at 16 by bentlegen on Sunday January 15, 2012 @11:14PM (#3469338)
Hyperbole.
Re:Programming prodigy passes away at 16 by habitatforus on Sunday January 15, 2012 @08:10PM (#3468897)
Found my old password and logged in just to upvote this comment.

Any child driven enough to do all this at a young age would have accomplished much more down the road.

This is one of those negative sum situations where we all loose.

Re:Programming prodigy passes away at 16 by protomyth on Sunday January 15, 2012 @11:55PM (#3469428)
Pretty much did the same thing myself (stopped feeling good about commenting on anything). Her drive and humble demeanor were evident from the interviews she gave. Her death is a loss.
Re:Programming prodigy passes away at 16 by chacham15 on Monday January 16, 2012 @03:52AM (#3469936)
Death in general is a loss. I know that this view is a bit simple-minded, but I believe that everyone has a part to play in the world and it is unfortunate that her part stops here. On the positive side, I hope that her life inspired others so that she may live on in them.
Re:Programming prodigy passes away at 16 by harichinnan on Monday January 16, 2012 @01:04AM (#3469574)
I feel really sorry for her parents. However your sympathy stems from ignorance of the Indian sub-continent. Middle class kids in India, and I assume Pakistan have the opposite problem of what you say. They are pressured into achieving academic success come what may. The Indian IITs select .5% of the applicants. Delhi university sometimes rejects applicants getting 98% in school because there are many who get even more. Many of them go through multiple "coaching/tuition" classes in addition to going to school. Celebrating someone for obtaining an MCP certificate in addition to grueling coursework actually has a negative effect on already over-burdened kids.
Re:Programming prodigy passes away at 16 by suhastech on Monday January 16, 2012 @06:44AM (#3470308)
I definitely agree.

I always get yelled at by my parents because I do a lot of computer programming instead of studying.

There's minimal encouragement in this society and I've seen parents pushing kids to get into CS because it pays. Environment has lot to do in making a "genius". And maybe that's why we have crappy programmers here, in India, and the deviants are pulled into the stereotype.

Assuming Pakistan is similar to India, this girl programming at such a young age is definitely a great deal. I don't think people in the first world nations understand this.

Re:Programming prodigy passes away at 16 by mechanical_fish on Sunday January 15, 2012 @11:08PM (#3469326)
Thanks for the moderation efforts. You've saved me a lot of misery by convincing me to read no further.
Re:Programming prodigy passes away at 16 by rbanffy on Monday January 16, 2012 @06:03AM (#3470232)
Geeks, and I am guilty of that myself, often miss the greater point and discuss endlessly increasingly narrow aspects of much larger issues. It's within our nature to do it.

But that doesn't mean we can't understand this drive to discuss the details, fight our little demons, and raise our heads to look at the forest instead of the trees.

This girl, in her short life, accomplished more than many of us ever will. Her loss at this age is tragic, but even more tragic is the loss of what she would have become. We need more people like her.

Re:Programming prodigy passes away at 16 by dan00 on Monday January 16, 2012 @05:52AM (#3470208)
"Whatever your motivation, jealousy, a general misunderstanding of the station of women in many third world countries or any other thing that might have prompted you to write what you wrote here: Let me tell you straight from the heart that I think this girl was everything you in particular should aspire to be."

HN is going to be the typical IT community: big egos fighting against each other to show off their smartness.

If now a young girl is called a genius, then they can't resist to nitpick, because they feel overlooked in their megalomania, they should deserve this title.

Re:Programming prodigy passes away at 16 by larve on Monday January 16, 2012 @01:56AM (#3469684)
HN is a community, so this site is mostly about communication between humans, and empathy is an important part of that. People telling that it is not a big deal, and that the story is hyped, are I think jealous of not having been featured in the same way. It's the media, so things usually get a bit distorted. But then we have stories about panda bears dying that make headlines as well.

Even if you were a nine year old girl in Pakistan having written something that people here would recognize as valuable, something like writing a url parsing module in node.js, would you post a comment questioning her achievements? Think back when you were nine, wouldn't you have loved to hear about her? I remember that when I was nine and starting programming, I had heard a terrible hard time grasping simple BASIC programs. I went on to become a fairly capable developer, and event got my share of overblown headlines at 16. Nothing bugs me about a girl getting the same, and being so incredibly much wiser and inspirational than I was. Writing a calculator in C# at 9, studying for an exam that adults take, and then being incredibly intelligent and sensible about it is a big achievement.

There are all these threads about CS education, codeacademy, etc... on here. Well that is what they are all about.

What bothers me even more is people going all free speech when someone is questioning their post. Seriously? In their place, I would start questioning what compelled me to write such a post, and why this story caught my interest so much as to write a comment saying that earning an MCP is not worth mentioning.