Re:Shaking Ordinary Ice (Hard) Transformed It into Something...
by ghaff on Monday February 06, 2023 @10:55AM
(#34679219)
Having a grad degree in material science I personally understand the distinction between amorphous and crystalline ice and might find that headline intriguing. I suspect it would be a turnoff for the average Times reader.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Shaking Ordinary Ice (Hard) Transformed It into Something...
by fnordpiglet on Monday February 06, 2023 @12:03PM
(#34680415)
Do you find the times article bait and switch? My reading was it is something never seen before, and I found it interesting and exciting and the properties discussed seemed unique (the pressure+heat=lots of energy particularly). But as an expert in the field, is the headline over stating the result to entice clicks?
Re:Shaking Ordinary Ice (Hard) Transformed It into Something...
by ghaff on Monday February 06, 2023 @12:16PM
(#34680621)
>Do you find the times article bait and switch?
No.
It's accurate if unspecific. The dek is also a good teaser. "medium-density amorphous ice" is mentioned in the photo caption at the top. And the lede is both clever and summarizes things at a layman's level.
I'm not really an expert on ice. My thesis advisor is but I actually worked on Nickel Aluminides though that branch of my thesis advisor's work never ended up really going anywhere. But this seems like a very reasonable (and readable) article for a mainstream audience on the topic.
Sure. I might like to see some phase diagrams, etc. but I don't expect that in a newspaper.
Re:Shaking Ordinary Ice (Hard) Transformed It into Something...
by klyrs on Monday February 06, 2023 @02:29PM
(#34682836)
Same (though, my physics background is much weaker than yours). However, I'm mad about two things in the headline and lay-article. The headline says "shaken hard" and the image caption says "obtained by putting ice in a bowl with steel balls." The article is clear, they put ice in a ball mill. They ground the ice up at low temperature. They didn't just shake it, they didn't just put ice and steel in a bowl. Jeez.