Re:Poll: Do you use app hosting or run your own server?
by callmeed on Sunday January 15, 2012 @12:52AM
(#3466486)
Don't forget that Heroku/AWS aren't immune to outages themselves. Their major outage last year (due to an AWS/EBS issue) put my app out of commission for ~16 hours (fortunately it was still in a small, private beta).
I've got 6 VPSes and 12 dedicated boxes and have never had an outage that long (self-inflicted or otherwise) in roughly 6 years. Granted, most of my dedicated boxes are managed by Rackspace and cost > $1k/month.
All that to say, I agree with your sentiments for the most part ... I just haven't seen the "prevention" of catastrophic events per say.
Re:Poll: Do you use app hosting or run your own server?
by mattvanhorn on Sunday January 15, 2012 @01:10AM
(#3466505)
The company I work for experienced a two hour outage several days ago, with a Rackspace hosted stack. It was a hardware failure of some sort, most likely a disk in our DB server.
Nothing is really 100% fail-proof, and each "9" that you want costs an order of magnitude more than the last. I've been happy with Heroku overall, even though their major outage affected me pretty badly last year. They have learned from it, and don't expect they'll get caught by the same thing again. And they are much better at managing servers than I am.
("Dammit, Jim, I'm a coder not a sysop!")
Re:Poll: Do you use app hosting or run your own server?
by wyuenho on Sunday January 15, 2012 @06:02AM
(#3466907)
Heroku, GAE and other SaSS are great, if and only if they have everything you need. For my own purposes, most of the things that I do now involves PostGIS which mean I have to use a PostgreSQL server. The cheapest option for PostgreSQL on Heroku starts at $200. That's just way out of my budget for now. I'd love to know how people do GeoSpatial searches and other GIS stuff using MySQL or other NoSQL solutions.
Re:Poll: Do you use app hosting or run your own server?
by jonknee on Sunday January 15, 2012 @09:25AM
(#3467182)
MongoDB might be interesting for you to look at. It has geospatial stuff baked in.
Re:Poll: Do you use app hosting or run your own server?
by aphexairlines on Sunday January 15, 2012 @05:03AM
(#3466835)
Couldn't you migrate BCC to EC2 and then migrate pieces of it into Elastic Beanstalk (or AppEngine, or Heroku) as you wrap thin service layers around each piece?
These days I'm attempting to move things off of my VPSes where there are good, stable options which don't require huge engineering efforts to use. SendGrid for email was an early, obvious choice. I'll be migrating many of my blogs to WPEngine fairly soon. (I'll write up my rationale for that at length after it happens. They're a client, so take my arguments with a grain of salt, but it became painfully obvious when working with them that it was the right call.)
If I got a do-over on my two main software products I would probably re-write them to use Heroku over self-hosting them on my VPS. It would have avoided ~6 minor service disruptions and ~2 catastrophes in the last year, plus saved me about two weeks of lost billable time. (Mostly lost due to having a very involved migration from Slicehost to Rackspace which went fairly poorly, principally due to failing to invest another few weeks preparing thoroughly for it.)
I can't justify a rewrite of BCC or AR at the moment to migrate to Heroku, though, as they're both multiple weeks of work with high probability of breaking something, and my anticipated costs due to I'm Not Always A Sysadmin But When I Am I Only Fail On The Hard Stuff this year don't quite justify it. (Please, please, nobody buy Rackspace to shut it down. One migration was enough.)