Re:British student may be extradited to US on copyright charges
by scottdw2 on Monday January 16, 2012 @09:08PM
(#3473463)
Don't English and Welsh law allow for private prosecution of crimes in cases where the CPS declines to prosecute?
Wouldn't that provide an avenue of relief to the copy right holders without removing a UK citizen from the jurisdiction of UK laws?
This whole thing seems troubling to me.
How many US Internet companies collect VAT from sales to folks in the UK? Would that make founders of a US startup subject to extradition to the UK for tax avoidance? What if it's just a tiny DBA "company" with no liability shield?
The whole thing smells rotten to me!
The judge, theoretically, is more of the expert on the law and whether it should be tried - but the CPS have to decide to bring the prosecution to him/her. Which is why you regularly get cases that should be seen in court, but which a suit decides is statistically unlikely to prosecute favourably.