News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:ChatGPT Passes Google Coding Interview for Level 3 Engine... by SpeedilyDamage on Saturday February 04, 2023 @02:03PM (#34657065)
You don't understand the take that just because ChatGPT can pass a coding interview doesn't mean the coding interview is useless or that ChatGPT could actually do the job?

What part of that take do you not understand? It's a really easy concept to grasp, and even if you don't agree with it, I would expect at least that a research scientist (according to your bio) would be able to grok the concepts almost immediately...

Re:ChatGPT Passes Google Coding Interview for Level 3 Engine... by brhsagain on Saturday February 04, 2023 @02:15PM (#34657179)
> doesn't mean the coding interview is useless or that ChatGPT could actually do the job

Aren't these kind of mutually exclusive, at least directionally? If the interview is meaningful you'd expect it to predict job performance. If it can't predict job performance then it is kind of useless.

I guess you could play some word games here to occupy a middle ground ("the coding interview is kind of useful, it measures something, just not job performance exactly") but I can't think of a formulation where this doesn't sound pretty silly.

Re:ChatGPT Passes Google Coding Interview for Level 3 Engine... by ianbutler on Saturday February 04, 2023 @02:20PM (#34657227)
We've been saying for years these interviews are not predictive of job performance. Here's the proof.

Nothing you do in an interview like this resembles day to day work in this field.

Re:ChatGPT Passes Google Coding Interview for Level 3 Engine... by SpeedilyDamage on Saturday February 04, 2023 @03:00PM (#34657609)
For what it's worth, when I ask these kinds of questions (rarely anymore), I'm looking more at how the problem is solved, not what the solution is.

A wrong answer with good thinking is better than a correct answer with no explanation.

Re:ChatGPT Passes Google Coding Interview for Level 3 Engine... by jokethrowaway on Saturday February 04, 2023 @03:11PM (#34657729)
Chatgpt can provide you a great explanation of the how.

Oftentimes the explanation is correct, even if there's some mistake in the code (probably because the explanation is easier to generate than the correct code, an artifact of being a high tech parrot)

Re:ChatGPT Passes Google Coding Interview for Level 3 Engine... by morelisp on Saturday February 04, 2023 @02:50PM (#34657514)
Finding a single counterexample does not disprove correlation or predictive ability. A hiring test can have both false positives and false negatives and still be useful.
Re:ChatGPT Passes Google Coding Interview for Level 3 Engine... by l33t233372 on Saturday February 04, 2023 @04:26PM (#34658478)
It’s possible that being able to pass the interview is indicative of performance in humans but not in LLMs.

Humans think differently from LLMs so it makes sense to interpret the same signal in different ways.

Re:ChatGPT Passes Google Coding Interview for Level 3 Engine... by hacym on Saturday February 04, 2023 @02:07PM (#34657102)
I don’t think your militant attitude helps them understand any better.
Re:ChatGPT Passes Google Coding Interview for Level 3 Engine... by SpeedilyDamage on Saturday February 04, 2023 @02:20PM (#34657223)
I don't think I had a militant attitude, but I do think saying, "I don't understand..." rather than "I disagree with..." puts a sour note on the entire conversation.
Re:ChatGPT Passes Google Coding Interview for Level 3 Engine... by mensetmanusman on Saturday February 04, 2023 @02:38PM (#34657419)
I was just responding to the ‘water is blue’ level dismissal of a seemingly clear advancement. Sorry it seemed like a sour note— not my intent:)
Re:ChatGPT Passes Google Coding Interview for Level 3 Engine... by SpeedilyDamage on Saturday February 04, 2023 @02:59PM (#34657598)
All good, it's just hard sometimes to understand intent online, maybe I overreacted to what I perceived as bad faith engagement.

Words are hard!

Re:ChatGPT Passes Google Coding Interview for Level 3 Engine... by hacym on Saturday February 04, 2023 @02:53PM (#34657538)
You literally went to their profile and called them out about how they should be able to understand something you’re describing as so easy to understand.
Re:ChatGPT Passes Google Coding Interview for Level 3 Engine... by SpeedilyDamage on Saturday February 04, 2023 @02:59PM (#34657591)
Yeah, what is the problem with that? They engaged dishonestly by claiming they didn't understand something, why should I do anything other than call them on that?
Re:ChatGPT Passes Google Coding Interview for Level 3 Engine... by hacym on Saturday February 04, 2023 @03:01PM (#34657622)
OK — just don’t be surprised when people think you’re being a jerk because you didn’t like the words someone chose. I’d assert you’re acting in bad faith more than the person you responded to.
Re:ChatGPT Passes Google Coding Interview for Level 3 Engine... by SpeedilyDamage on Saturday February 04, 2023 @03:50PM (#34658115)
I just... how is what you're doing here different from what I was saying, other than you're explicitly calling me names?
Re:ChatGPT Passes Google Coding Interview for Level 3 Engine... by hacym on Saturday February 04, 2023 @03:59PM (#34658222)
> engaged dishonestly by claiming [someone used a word they didn’t like] why should I do anything other than call them on that?

Have a great day.

Re:ChatGPT Passes Google Coding Interview for Level 3 Engine... by SpeedilyDamage on Saturday February 04, 2023 @04:23PM (#34658444)
...what? I'm so confused.
Re:ChatGPT Passes Google Coding Interview for Level 3 Engine... by hacym on Saturday February 04, 2023 @05:08PM (#34658911)
It’s really very easy to understand. When someone gives you the same crap back that you just got done giving someone, you don’t like it and act like that shouldn’t happen.
Re:ChatGPT Passes Google Coding Interview for Level 3 Engine... by SpeedilyDamage on Saturday February 04, 2023 @05:14PM (#34658965)
Did I say I didn't "like" (I'd use the word "appreciate") it, or that I didn't think it should happen? If so, could you please highlight where?

I just see, in what you're doing, a wild lack of self awareness. You're criticizing me for doing to someone else a milder version of what you're trying to do to me now; I'm genuinely confused how you can't see that, or how you could possibly stand the hypocrisy if you do understand that.

Re:ChatGPT Passes Google Coding Interview for Level 3 Engine... by hacym on Saturday February 04, 2023 @06:51PM (#34659799)
I feel that you’re being dishonest if you are saying you’re confused or don’t understand my point.
Re:ChatGPT Passes Google Coding Interview for Level 3 Engine... by SpeedilyDamage on Sunday February 05, 2023 @12:13AM (#34662143)
I can't change how you feel.
Re:ChatGPT Passes Google Coding Interview for Level 3 Engine... by jokethrowaway on Saturday February 04, 2023 @03:10PM (#34657695)
I'll try to phrase it so that even someone who is not a research scientist (?) can understand. I'm not one, whatever that means.

Let's define the interview as useful if the passing candidate can do the job.

Sounds reasonable.

ChatGPT can pass the interview and can't do the job.

The interview is not able to predict the poor working performance of ChatGPT and it's therefore useless.

Some of the companies I worked for hired ex fang people as if it was a mark of quality, but that hasn't always worked out well. There is plenty of people getting out of fangs having just done mediocre work for a big paycheck.

Re:ChatGPT Passes Google Coding Interview for Level 3 Engine... by thaumasiotes on Saturday February 04, 2023 @05:19PM (#34659015)
> Let's define the interview as useful if the passing candidate can do the job.

The technical term for this is "construct validity", that the test results are related to something you want to learn about.

> The interview is not able to predict the poor working performance of ChatGPT and it's therefore useless.

This doesn't follow; the interview doesn't need to be able to exclude ChatGPT because ChatGPT doesn't interview for jobs. It's perfectly possible that the same test shows high validity on humans and low validity on ChatGPT.