Re:British student may be extradited to US on copyright charges
by mjwalshe on Saturday January 14, 2012 @06:21PM
(#3465654)
so if a murderer or rapist managed to leave the US would you still say so?
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:British student may be extradited to US on copyright charges
by potatolicious on Saturday January 14, 2012 @11:13PM
(#3466317)
Not the same though - if a murderer fled the US, the crime was still committed on US soil, by someone in the US at the time, against (presumably) a US resident/citizen. In other words, it's rightfully American business.
The other country would simply be returning the person to the correct jurisdiction.
Note that even this is not clear-cut at all - many countries will refuse extradition even in this case if there is evidence that the person will face the death sentence or torture.
The USA simply doesn't have the right to prosecute crimes abroad, with no relation to the USA whatsoever - whether in defense of its citizenry or its corporations. That's what the whole concept of sovereignty is about!