Re:Colombian judge used ChatGPT to make court decision
by fnordpiglet on Saturday February 04, 2023 @11:54AM
(#34655876)
Note if you read it carefully he only included the responses but wrote parallel arguments and then synthesized the two. So, like I said, it was reviewed.
It’s like complaining engineers use Monte Carlo simulations, which are random, to do analyses of structural integrity instead of doing all the calculations using a human computer[1]. I see these LLM chatbots as being akin to a computational tool like a calculator. It’s great for crunching and provides a force multiplier for a skilled person using it to augment their own abilities, but it’s (not yet) a replacement for the expert.
That's a judgment call because "favorable" is subjective. Someone who gets sent to jail for 1 year might tell you the prosecutor got a favorable ruling while the prosecutor considers it unfavorable because they wanted the person sentenced to 5 years.