Re:Why Did the Beatles Get So Many Bad Reviews?
by galaxyLogic on Saturday February 04, 2023 @01:00AM
(#34651960)
> But it seems unnecessary?
If something is extremely popular but you perceive something wrong about it of course that's a good reason to write about it.
At the same time many critics seem to just try to put artists down because that makes it seem the critic is above the artist because he can see the wrongness in the artist. Critics are wannabe artists.
Re:Why Did the Beatles Get So Many Bad Reviews?
by skybrian on Saturday February 04, 2023 @02:50AM
(#34652581)
I don't see any upside in trying to tell people that some music they love is crap.
It's different for other media, like an article about how a book or TV show or movie is historically inaccurate is sometimes fun.
Re:Why Did the Beatles Get So Many Bad Reviews?
by pbhjpbhj on Saturday February 04, 2023 @06:42AM
(#34653696)
Why is it different for music, to the situation with movies, say? Music can have a narrative that is counter factual too.
Re:Why Did the Beatles Get So Many Bad Reviews?
by skybrian on Saturday February 04, 2023 @10:35AM
(#34655203)
Can you name a song with lyrics that you'd consider to be misinformation rather than poetry or fiction? Seems like it would be pretty rare.
Re:Why Did the Beatles Get So Many Bad Reviews?
by galaxyLogic on Sunday February 05, 2023 @02:48AM
(#34662839)
> I don't see any upside in trying to tell people that some music they love is crap.
I guess it's just the wrongheaded logic of criticism: The critic must prove they are doing their job. They are "critics", right? Therefore they must criticize. :-)
I look around on YouTube for recordings I like. There are lots of recordings I don't like for whatever reason. I don't post them. Why bother?
So, nowadays, I'm not sure why anyone should spend time reviewing music they don't like. At all. What's the point? The slush pile is vast. Make the best collection you can of stuff you like. If other people find it good then maybe they'll start to trust your judgement.
Admittedly, I have a tiny audience, a newspaper is a little different, and sometimes people like to read a good takedown. But it seems unnecessary?