Re:The White House's Response to SOPA
by ajross on Saturday January 14, 2012 @09:47AM
(#3464318)
No, the DMCA doesn't work like that. It doesn't require any action by the site owner at all. It simply says that if you demand removal in the proper manner and the content is removed from the site promptly, then the site owner cannot be held liable for any infringement. In practice, site owners are very responsive to DMCA demands from "big content" and pretty much ignore them from everyone else.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:The White House's Response to SOPA
by Silhouette on Saturday January 14, 2012 @01:07PM
(#3464792)
> In practice, site owners are very responsive to DMCA demands from "big content" and pretty much ignore them from everyone else.
That isn't even FUD, it's an outright lie. Please take your unfounded allegations and conspiracy theories elsewhere.
(I work with/know personally several people/small organisations who are content producers, whose work has been widely ripped off, but who have been quite successful at limiting their unwanted exposure on the big name content sharing sites because of DMCA takedown notices and similar provisions elsewhere in the world.)
Granted, the plural of anecdote is not data, but I've filed six DMCA takedown notices for photographs I've placed under Creative Commons licenses but were not used according to the terms of those licenses. Every company I dealt with took swift action to take down the infringing material.
I am sure those were reasonable demands but the proposition here is for a nuisance "work to rule" campaign. Understanding the political motivation, the big companies could call your bluff and wait for a court order, expensive to obtain.
Not a real downside risk, but my point is that the circumstances are not directly comparable once the intention is to kick the hornet's nest.