News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Amazon reports its first unprofitable year since 2014 by blinding-streak on Friday February 03, 2023 @09:07AM (#34641189)
AWS specifically reported 20% YoY revenue growth, which is the lowest it's ever been since they started reporting the numbers publicly.
Re:Amazon reports its first unprofitable year since 2014 by ElevenLathe on Friday February 03, 2023 @09:20AM (#34641301)
Teams at every single AWS customer, big and small, have probably spent the last quarter finding and ending wasteful, forgotten spend lurking in their cloud footprint in a desperate attempt to prove to their MBAs that they shouldn't be in the next round of layoffs because they just saved the company 10x their salary in cloud spend.

I know I have.

Re:Amazon reports its first unprofitable year since 2014 by simplotek on Friday February 03, 2023 @09:40AM (#34641536)
> Teams at every single AWS customer, big and small, have probably spent the last quarter finding and ending wasteful, forgotten spend lurking in their cloud footprint

The interesting thing about cloud costs for companies like Amazon or AWS is that in the short term it's only an accounting trick. The company is not spending money if there's a lambda deployed somewhere, or a EC3 instance idling. It's nice to erode revenue in the books from these expenses, but it's not like Besos needs to reach out of his wallet to cover the cost of a container launched by some random team at Amazon. At most he moves the cash from one pocket to the other and there's that.

Re:Amazon reports its first unprofitable year since 2014 by ElevenLathe on Friday February 03, 2023 @09:47AM (#34641648)
Well, they don't need to spend money to schedule my Lambda, but they did already spend a bunch of money building out the datacenter so they can pick up my 100th of a nickel when they do schedule it.

AWS is kind of like a bank, making money on the spread between the cost of compute at different time scales. They can get cheap compute (by committing to owning datacenters and filling them with silicon) and sell expensive compute by letting customers buy it by the second. This is a great business if the demand for per-second compute is always rising, but it isn't if all your customers suddenly take you up on it all at once and start spending drastically less but you huge datacenter investment is illiquid.

Re:Amazon reports its first unprofitable year since 2014 by simplotek on Friday February 03, 2023 @09:56AM (#34641801)
> Well, they don't need to spend money to schedule my Lambda, but they did already spend a bunch of money building out the datacenter so they can pick up my 100th of a nickel when they do schedule it.

A projected revenue drop is not the same as a loss though. You already bought that computer.

Less so if it's your own company who was using their stuff.

Worst case scenario: they have stuff idling and more headroom to accommodate demand.

Heck, why waste more money building yet another data center if the ones already in place have already plenty of cycles rand bandwidth to spare?

It's all an accounting trick. You don't waste more power. You don't have to but more hardware. Turning off your lambda saves nothing.

Re:Amazon reports its first unprofitable year since 2014 by ElevenLathe on Friday February 03, 2023 @11:30AM (#34643382)
You're right that it's probably not that a big deal for Amazon since it's all mainly financed by their own cash flow, but in general it can be a problem if there is debt (that you took out to build the datacenters) to service. Also, those servers are depreciating (in the literal sense of becoming less valuable over time, not in the accounting sense of spreading their cost out over several fiscal years for tax purposes) while still not making them any money, so the "lifetime earnings" of their existing silicon will be less than they would otherwise have been without a slowdown.

I'm not sure what the "accounting trick" is though, except in the sense that anything involving money or finance is an accounting trick. Can you elaborate?

Re:Amazon reports its first unprofitable year since 2014 by londons_explore on Friday February 03, 2023 @09:24AM (#34641362)
> they just saved the company 10x their salary in cloud spend.

Great. Thanks for doing that. Now that we have got our cloud costs manageable, the next biggest expense is people!

What did you say you did again? Oh, you're our cloud cost reduction guy? I don't think we need your skills anymore, that's not a problem anymore.

Re:Amazon reports its first unprofitable year since 2014 by ElevenLathe on Friday February 03, 2023 @09:36AM (#34641498)
I've had that thought too, but I'm playing a tactical game rather than a strategic one at this point. The name of the game is to survive the next few quarters. Also, there is a team whose job /is/ cloud cost reduction but all they ever seem to do is spend /more/ on enormously huge Glue jobs, Athena queries, etc.
Re:Amazon reports its first unprofitable year since 2014 by lumost on Friday February 03, 2023 @09:51AM (#34641713)
The snake eats its own tail? This is why layoffs are imprecise, everyone starts pointing fingers. If the cloud cost reduction team only ever increased costs for 2-3 years... then there is a leadership problem for letting it continue. Otherwise the cloud cost reduction team probably was doing something else for leadership.
Re:Amazon reports its first unprofitable year since 2014 by ElevenLathe on Friday February 03, 2023 @10:17AM (#34642141)
Not pointing fingers (it's not my money they're spending keeping the other team in business), just saying that if the logic is "actually, our cloud spend looks better than ever, maybe we can lay off the people whose job it is to do that?" then they are not looking at me because I have a different title. My big saves are all in the category of "I was in there anyway and noticed that X was enabled. Do we need that on?" so I look like a thoughtful engineer who is alert for waste.

Anyway all of this is a bit of a joke obviously. I know that layoff decisions aren't going to be made based on looking at individual people, or even teams. Still, it can't really hurt me to save my employer money (as long as it isn't my own salary, or my colleagues' salary), especially in a tough macro environment.

Perhaps I'm even saving some significant amount of emissions and therefore marginally delaying the end of all human life, or marginally reducing demand for energy at a time when it's tight. Thousands of engineers doing the same all at once can probably significantly hurt the hyperscalers' business though.

Re:Amazon reports its first unprofitable year since 2014 by leanstartupnoob on Friday February 03, 2023 @09:42AM (#34641569)
> Oh, you're our cloud cost reduction guy? I don't think we need your skills anymore, that's not a problem anymore.

That's a somewhat cynical view, but I'm sure there are plenty of other MBAs looking for people with proven experience cutting cloud costs.

Re:Amazon reports its first unprofitable year since 2014 by sebazzz on Saturday February 04, 2023 @01:47AM (#34652238)
I know how you can cut cloud costs. It doesn't involve the big4 cloud.
Re:Amazon reports its first unprofitable year since 2014 by gregshap on Friday February 03, 2023 @10:04AM (#34641919)
This, except it's the MBA+5 talking to the MBA+2
Re:Amazon reports its first unprofitable year since 2014 by esskay on Friday February 03, 2023 @09:43AM (#34641578)
Yep we did the same. Saved about 10k/mo by clearing out old junk we dont need anymore and consolodating things.
Re:Amazon reports its first unprofitable year since 2014 by nicoburns on Friday February 03, 2023 @10:13AM (#34642070)
I don't understand why this is considered anything other than normal. It's not possible for companies to continue growing forever and it's innevitable that growth will start to slow as the company matures.