News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:What the Bagel Man Saw - An Accidental Glimpse at Human N... by nkurz on Friday January 13, 2012 @03:14PM (#3462195)
if you consider the honor box a suggested donation box, is that a business

A fine question, and an ongoing local issue near me: http://online.wsj.com/article/SB123422026431565295.html A local Thai temple has a mandatory voluntary donation scheme that they use to skirt a lot of laws. I love their food, but am against their sham.

The sales tax is likely included in the dollar amount.

Could be, but I'd bet that he's technically non-compliant. The rules are mighty complex. Our next-door neighbor restaurant was recently fined heavily for considering their sandwich purchases "take out" while providing unofficial side-walk seating.

We (well, specifically, I) don't know if DC requires permits for re-selling food-stuff.

If we are to consider it a "sale", then I think he would require a Vending Machine License: http://dc.gov/DC/DCRA/For+Business/Apply+for+a+Business+Lice...

It probably depends on how much revenue is produced by each location.

I deal with many such laws in California, and have not found many such exclusions. Rather, like speeding, the behaviour is technically illegal but regulated with only selective enforcement. I don't like selective enforcement.

Just as sidewalk Lemonade stands don't require permits, in most locales.

I think this is again mostly selective enforcement. It's been a big issue lately: http://www.forbes.com/sites/erikkain/2011/08/03/the-inexplic...

Anyhow, all that is speculative, unless you have facts.

True. I can really only speak only to my experience running a food business in California, where my opinion is that it is impossible to run a business without breaking numerous laws. Heck, I just learned last month that all of my employees are working illegally: http://sanfrancisco.grubstreet.com/2011/06/so_has_anyone_in_...

If someone else goes against ethics, does it grant me a waiver to act unethically?

This is indeed the real question. It certainly doesn't grant an unconditional waiver, but I think there can be mitigating factors. Would it matter that the Bagel Guy has the permission of the business (he does)? What if he was representing it as a charity: http://bulkvending.blogspot.com/2008/04/making-money-from-ch...

I think the question is ethics. While the article was entertaining, it didn't delve deeply enough into the situation to be informative on ethics. I post to HN hoping that discussion might be able to happen here...

There are no comments on this comment yet.