News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:New York City gets a Software Engineering High School by rgrieselhuber on Friday January 13, 2012 @12:05PM (#3461339)
Religion class aside, it seems a loss to do away with geography, philosophy and foreign languages. I love that you guys had a shell and learned so many great tools, but I think programming is also enhanced by being exposed to many non-CS topics.
Re:New York City gets a Software Engineering High School by pbz on Friday January 13, 2012 @12:58PM (#3461585)
Don't worry, they drill more geography in you before high school than they do here throughout high school. Teaching foreign languages starts from kindergarten. By high school if you're inclined and had good teachers you should know enough to have an ok conversation in at least two different languages. Plus you get exposed to so much to English / Spanish (you hear the original soundtrack for every movie for example) that you could learn a lot just from listening. I'm not sure about philosophy though, that would be a loss.(salutari)
Re:New York City gets a Software Engineering High School by yummyfajitas on Friday January 13, 2012 @12:58PM (#3461588)
Compare unemployment rates in geography, philosophy and foreign languages. We need more CS people. We don't need more philosophers.

(Though admittedly, knowledge of English or German might be very useful if you are coming from Romania.)

Re:New York City gets a Software Engineering High School by rdouble on Friday January 13, 2012 @02:56PM (#3462104)
According to census data from 2010, foreign language majors have a lower unemployment rate (5.2%) than computer science majors (5.6%). Geography (6.1%) and philosophy and religion (7.1%) don't fare as well, but are doing about as well as computer engineers (7.0%).

Worst off are clinical psychologists (19.1%), best off (0%) are actuaries, pharmacists, school administrators, and surprisingly, geologists and astronomers (!).

http://graphicsweb.wsj.com/documents/NILF1111/#term=

Re:New York City gets a Software Engineering High School by yummyfajitas on Friday January 13, 2012 @05:11PM (#3462623)
I stand corrected, foreign languages are probably also a worthwhile field of study.
Re:New York City gets a Software Engineering High School by botker on Friday January 13, 2012 @02:14PM (#3461910)
We don't need more Continental philosophers. We need all the Analytic philosophers we can get. A curriculum that emphasizes rigorous thinking skills and logic is an invaluable foundation for CS as well as every other valuable human endeavor.
Re:New York City gets a Software Engineering High School by Daniel_Newby on Friday January 13, 2012 @10:53PM (#3463414)
Philosophy also teaches one to carefully define terms and examine underlying assumptions. Clearly stating the problem often makes the solution obvious.
Re:New York City gets a Software Engineering High School by jmduke on Friday January 13, 2012 @02:45PM (#3462064)
This is the wrong way to think about education. Learning is learning, regardless of job placement, and while I recognize the need for stronger STEM education it shouldn't come at the expense of equally important topics.
Re:New York City gets a Software Engineering High School by yummyfajitas on Friday January 13, 2012 @03:01PM (#3462125)
Learning is good only if it either enables you do to something useful or you enjoy it. If you don't enjoy it (many people don't), focus on learning that lets you do something useful. High job placement gives an indication that a field is useful.

As for learning you do because you enjoy it, treat it as consumption (i.e., the same way you treat an X-Box).

Re:New York City gets a Software Engineering High School by ericd on Friday January 13, 2012 @05:19PM (#3462645)
You cannot know what you will find useful in the future. A broad education helps inform your decisions on a huge variety of subjects, even without realizing it. Learning only what you think you'll need for your future profession is a really terrible idea.
Re:New York City gets a Software Engineering High School by yummyfajitas on Friday January 13, 2012 @05:40PM (#3462719)
With certainty, no. So what? The right question to ask is this: Is P(need subject X) x (cost of not knowing X) < (cost of learning X)?

Since the cost of learning X tends to be high (at least if you learn it in school), and the cost of not knowing it is very often nothing but the cost of learning it + cost of delays, this inequality is very often not satisfied.

Re:New York City gets a Software Engineering High School by ericd on Saturday January 14, 2012 @03:19AM (#3463802)
I'm not talking about certainty. I'm saying that humans are impossibly bad at figuring out the first two variables in that equation, and only slightly better at figuring out the cost of learning.

And the opportunity cost of not knowing things can be staggering.

If you just want to maximize your wealth, maybe that approach is workable, since there are more tangible numbers involved, but if you're optimizing for happiness, it's much, much harder.

Re:New York City gets a Software Engineering High School by jmduke on Friday January 13, 2012 @06:02PM (#3462790)
"Learning is good only if it either enables you do to something useful or you enjoy it."

I completely agree. But something is not only 'useful' if you can use it in your career.

Re:New York City gets a Software Engineering High School by rgrieselhuber on Friday January 13, 2012 @01:08PM (#3461622)
> We don't need more philosophers.

Agreed but imagine how boring CS would be if people were ignorant of all of those other subjects.

Re:New York City gets a Software Engineering High School by 32ftpersecond on Friday January 13, 2012 @01:49PM (#3461795)
> We don't need more philosophers.

Disagree. There would be no computer science without philosophy (but not the other way around).

> ...imagine how boring CS would be if people were ignorant of all of those other subjects.

If we eliminate philosophy from our curriculum, et cetera, I poise that kids entering high school this year will be obsolete by the time they have graduated. Because CS without philosophy is really just machine learning, right?

Re:New York City gets a Software Engineering High School by rgrieselhuber on Friday January 13, 2012 @02:59PM (#3462115)
That's a fair point. I was already regretting my agreement with that notion.
Re:New York City gets a Software Engineering High School by absconditus on Friday January 13, 2012 @02:27PM (#3461984)
So school should be thought of as nothing but a job training program?