News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The AI Crowd Is Mad by BolexNOLA on Wednesday February 01, 2023 @08:49AM (#34610340)
Correct me if I’m wrong, but aren’t systems like Midjourney inadvertently stealing from the people who are paid to make it?

Also, in some ways that’s like asking “why should I shop local when I can buy from Walmart and get the exact same product?“ Well obviously if it’s all down to simple dollar costs, you do you. But there are several motivations/considerations for choosing why we shop where we shop.

Re:The AI Crowd Is Mad by ben_w on Wednesday February 01, 2023 @08:56AM (#34610435)
Even lawyers aren't sure, the arguments can go either way: https://youtu.be/G08hY8dSrUY

Also note some new research: https://arxiv.org/abs/2301.13188

Re:The AI Crowd Is Mad by KaiserPro on Wednesday February 01, 2023 @09:17AM (#34610703)
So the legal thinking I have been reading is around the reproduction of copyrighted works.

However to get to a point where you _can_ recreate copyrighted works implies copyright infringement in the dataset. Thats not really been tackled.

Also, there is the GDPR angle here as well, collecting people's faces on the internet for something other than the person reasonably intended is also on grey legal ground I would argue.

Re:The AI Crowd Is Mad by NateEag on Wednesday February 01, 2023 @08:53AM (#34610389)
I suspect you're wrong that the stealing is inadvertent.

I'm suspicious the makers of the art generator AI systems know exactly what they're doing and see no issues with it.

Re:The AI Crowd Is Mad by Xelynega on Wednesday February 01, 2023 @08:57AM (#34610448)
If a bunch of random people on the internet see the potential copyright infringement and need for clarification, then it's doubtful makers of art generator algorithmsbdidnt think of the same potential issues and choose to ignore them.
Re:The AI Crowd Is Mad by Tostino on Wednesday February 01, 2023 @09:13AM (#34610654)
There are a whole bunch of people who think copyrights have held back progress, and this is a technological solution to allowing the sharing of information more freely.
Re:The AI Crowd Is Mad by BolexNOLA on Wednesday February 01, 2023 @08:56AM (#34610430)
I guess I’m just trying to be a little generous. They probably know it’s a risk and either rationalize it away with something along the lines of “well, it’s such a tiny minuscule piece from so many different people that it’s not really stealing“ or just pretend they don’t know. At this point the ignorance does seem willful.

Either way, I’m more just curious what other people how to say on the matter as I am not as knowledgeable of subject. I am on the creator side and it’s all bad news over here.

Re:The AI Crowd Is Mad by pixl97 on Wednesday February 01, 2023 @10:22AM (#34611699)
> “well, it’s such a tiny minuscule piece from so many different people that it’s not really stealing“

RMS wrote 'the right to read' because issues like this, and if you've not read it, I recommend you do. "A bunch of little bits of different things" isn't stealing, it's society and culture. If you got your wish of everything I create if fully copyrighted, you'd find two things. One, that you're last in line and don't come up with original ideas often, even in original artwork. And two, that monied corporations would quickly buy up rights to everything and make life as an artist completely impossible.

Re:The AI Crowd Is Mad by BolexNOLA on Wednesday February 01, 2023 @12:36PM (#34614246)
I'm not even sure that's what is happening to be honest, I'm just speculating as to how somehow could reason it away for themselves. I don't know what the line is for "too much inspiration" where it becomes stealing. I'll make sure to check that out though, appreciate it!
Re:The AI Crowd Is Mad by NateEag on Wednesday February 01, 2023 @10:54AM (#34612243)
Your choice to be generous is a kind and good one.

I don't have great insight into copyright issues, but as one who loves music and used to play a lot of it, I'm right there with you on the "it's all bad news over here".

It seems to me that the current crop of art generators ape styles but don't come up with their own.

I worry that if they put most human artists out of work, the arts will stagnate badly.

I guess we'll see.

Re:The AI Crowd Is Mad by BolexNOLA on Wednesday February 01, 2023 @12:37PM (#34614268)
>I worry that if they put most human artists out of work, the arts will stagnate badly.

Right there with you. And it's hard to even decide what qualifies as "adapt or die" you know? Do I just use AI-assisted tools? Do I "just" pivot my career and go somewhere else?