Re:Do We Live in a Society Without a Counterculture?
by omnicognate on Wednesday February 01, 2023 @06:54AM
(#34609310)
I don't think a movement can be called countercultural once it's taken over one of the two major US political parties and chosen a president.
Re:Do We Live in a Society Without a Counterculture?
by dcx on Wednesday February 01, 2023 @07:16AM
(#34609467)
I think we might still consider this counterculture as long as its norms are not mainstream culture. And I think it's fair to say the dominant culture of many cultural institutions in the US currently has a distinct leftward lean - Hollywood, news, education, research, social media, advertising, other large swathes of industry. (Which again, I'm not saying is a bad thing)
Also, Trump represented many things to many people, as opposed to just this emerging alt-right counterculture idea cloud. And by the numbers, most voters soundly rejected him in 2020.
Re:Do We Live in a Society Without a Counterculture?
by throwaway4aday on Wednesday February 01, 2023 @08:44AM
(#34610275)
90% of the people that would identify with those touchpoints listed above wouldn't and didn't vote for Trump. I think they get lumped in with die hard Trump supporters because they weren't buying in to the same paranoia and delusions that the rest of society was imbibing while Trump was in office.
I'm not saying I agree with or subscribe to the tenets of conservatism, but it's a natural process for the pendulum to swing as society advances. Liberal counterculture "won" and went completely mainstream. Which is great! Gay marriage is legal, we care about sustainability, and so on. But every system has gaps and blind spots, and movements which oppose the incumbent mainstream are, by definition, not liberal counterculture.
Some touchpoints - President Obama's failure to penalize banks in the Great Recession. One percenters and the new cathedral. Joe Rogan. The intellectual dark web (Jordan Peterson et al). The red pill. The alt right.
I feel many of the above are often stupid, but in the same way that there were a lot of stupid 60s counterculture movements. It doesn't invalidate the fact that valid ideas exist within both. Also, they aren't using your signaling channels - for example, music doesn't seem to be a relevant cultural rallying point any more.