Re:Mozilla concludes that JPEG-XL is not for them
by PaulHoule on Tuesday January 31, 2023 @02:55PM
(#34600967)
It makes me sad.
I used to run ‘large’ (millions of images) photo sites before and now I run some small ones.
Once a year for the last 5 years I considered new image formats would affect my practice, last year I finally found webp was an unambiguous winner over jpeg. (The bar is high. If you want to save both storage and transfer costs you can’t keep copies in many different formats.)
I found it was not so easy to do this analysis because I have not seen good studies of quality/size/processing speed and the ones that are there are limited. I’ve seen some where people compress the kind of images you might see in the header of a blog but look close and the images are awful. I take pictures with my DSLR and the photo could be the main content, it has to look really good.
I was unimpressed with AVIF last time, disappointed really, and liked the vision of JPEG XL much better. Maybe we should be lobbying browser vendors to drop AVIF because the same arguments that have against JXL would also work against AVIF.
I used to run ‘large’ (millions of images) photo sites before and now I run some small ones.
Once a year for the last 5 years I considered new image formats would affect my practice, last year I finally found webp was an unambiguous winner over jpeg. (The bar is high. If you want to save both storage and transfer costs you can’t keep copies in many different formats.)
I found it was not so easy to do this analysis because I have not seen good studies of quality/size/processing speed and the ones that are there are limited. I’ve seen some where people compress the kind of images you might see in the header of a blog but look close and the images are awful. I take pictures with my DSLR and the photo could be the main content, it has to look really good.
I was unimpressed with AVIF last time, disappointed really, and liked the vision of JPEG XL much better. Maybe we should be lobbying browser vendors to drop AVIF because the same arguments that have against JXL would also work against AVIF.