Re:The Law Does Not Require Legalese
by xboxnolifes on Tuesday January 31, 2023 @05:03AM
(#34593334)
Law is not science. There is nothing to test or discover. It is a declarative set of statements.
Re:The Law Does Not Require Legalese
by psychphysic on Tuesday January 31, 2023 @05:49AM
(#34593611)
Irrelevant
This is an interesting comment from a perspective of imprecise language, because the legal system uses the words "test" and "discover" frequently, but in a different meaning than yours.
Re:The Law Does Not Require Legalese
by andrekandre on Tuesday January 31, 2023 @08:41AM
(#34594870)
what is the meaning of "test" and "discover? in a legal system context?
Re:The Law Does Not Require Legalese
by psychphysic on Tuesday January 31, 2023 @05:52AM
(#34593631)
You're completely missing the reasoning by such a wide margin I can only assume it's intentional.
Ironically one of the top links on HN now is about good faith discussion.
Science is not built on precedent but on facts. Or one might even argue it's fashion with fact-based influences.
Many problems of our legal system stem from relying on precedent and not facts. But none of those are attributable to terminology.
> well I used the phrase "hullabaloo" because the court decided that previously it means "ruckus" but not necessarily "drunk"
Your examples of unclear language would not be a problem, at least in California, according to the article because those words and phrases are not mutually understood.
I think a bigger problem with "mutually understood" is that words and their meanings change. And we often don't agree on definitions. Dictionaries describe use. Literally now means figuratively. Dogs and cats are sleeping together.