But, I'm pretty sure the Surgeon General did not have HN in mind while making that comment. :)
HN is a social media, but it lacks certain capabilities that make it OK. First and foremost, there is no DM, then it's heavily moderated both by users as well as by DanG, and then it is text based. Also, based on my observation, the karma/like acquisition is not what drives people's comments here.
So, while you're correct that it's a social media, it's not the cesspool of poison that the usual ones, that come to mind when we use the term social media, are.
Downvotes are important for moderation and I think ‘anti-downvote’ upvotes are necessary as well as a check on downvotes, but apart from that I wonder if it wouldn’t be a less addictive and healthier site overall without upvotes, or at least without upvote numbers being visible.
I suppose this could be accomplished with an extension too.
Just because you don’t know the real world identity of the other nodes doesn’t mean that a network doesn’t exist.
You wouldn't classify HN as social media?