News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask HN: Why Is Everything Declining? by keiferski on Saturday January 28, 2023 @03:31PM (#34561496)
Some people think that aesthetics is entirely subjective. This is the default view of Western liberal democracies, especially among people that haven’t really thought much about the topic.

Some people, including a lot of philosophers and art theorists that can be considered “experts”, disagree. I would consider myself in this camp, although not a credentialed expert by any means. And no, I’m not “projecting my aesthetic” on to others, simply defending the idea of norms and expectations. This is a very different thing.

As I said in another comment, if you can’t get beyond the idea that Value is not entirely subjective and that everything isn’t just “your opinion, Dude,” then no argument is probably going to convince you of anything. Hence you will just end up in a situation like the OP posted about.

Re:Ask HN: Why Is Everything Declining? by meheleventyone on Saturday January 28, 2023 @03:36PM (#34561564)
How do you know what the objectively correct attire is and how did you measure it? And if you don’t know what it is then why would you say pyjamas aren’t it? Norms and expectations have varied wildly not just geographically in the present day but over time as well. To the point it was and actually is common to physically harm people.
Re:Ask HN: Why Is Everything Declining? by keiferski on Saturday January 28, 2023 @03:38PM (#34561575)
Just because multiple scales of value exist does not imply that all scales are equal or meaningless entirely.
Re:Ask HN: Why Is Everything Declining? by meheleventyone on Saturday January 28, 2023 @03:40PM (#34561597)
Right but that’s a non-answer because norms change over time and place and that can only happen if people are allowed to change them over time and place. All you’re saying is that it’s subjective in a clouded way. At best you’re basically being left behind the cultural norm and probably should catch up.
Re:Ask HN: Why Is Everything Declining? by keiferski on Saturday January 28, 2023 @03:50PM (#34561705)
No, it just means that norms should align with values. I have certain values and think that caring about aesthetics (personal appearance, nice architecture, clean spaces, beautiful art) results in a society that is better for me and other people.
Re:Ask HN: Why Is Everything Declining? by meheleventyone on Saturday January 28, 2023 @03:53PM (#34561732)
Yes, it’s your subjective opinion you want to force on everyone else but previously didn’t want to admit is the case because it shows there is no actual argument as to why anyone else should agree. Like the clashes over wearing headscarves in Iran where people are literally being killed an imprisoned over that subjective value disagreement.

“Everyone should share my values” is essentially an extreme position.

Re:Ask HN: Why Is Everything Declining? by keiferski on Saturday January 28, 2023 @03:58PM (#34561781)
Thinking that it’s beneficial for people to live in beautiful buildings without pollution is my subjective opinion?
Re:Ask HN: Why Is Everything Declining? by meheleventyone on Saturday January 28, 2023 @04:23PM (#34562054)
But you’ve changed the subject. We were discussing what people were wearing.

And as obvious yes if you personally think that it’s very acutely your subjective opinion. You are literally telling us your opinion. You couldn’t get a clearer example of something that’s subjective.

There’s a worrying level of philosophical paucity here.

Re:Ask HN: Why Is Everything Declining? by dragonwriter on Saturday January 28, 2023 @04:02PM (#34561824)
What is “beautiful” is, like, the textbook example of a subjective opinion.
Re:Ask HN: Why Is Everything Declining? by keiferski on Saturday January 28, 2023 @04:07PM (#34561882)
No, not really. The concept of beauty has a long philosophical history and many knowledgeable and intelligent people have written books on the topic. As I said above, the people who think this stuff is entirely subjective tend to be ones that haven’t engaged much (or at all) with previous thought on the topic.
Re:Ask HN: Why Is Everything Declining? by dragonwriter on Saturday January 28, 2023 @04:15PM (#34561954)
> The concept of beauty has a long philosophical history and many knowledgeable and intelligent people have written books on the topic

Which is not incompatible with it being subjective. In fact, many of those “knoweldgeable and intelligent” people have written specifically on its subjectivity, and others explicitly on specific, e.g., of a specific culture and time, subjective standards.

Re:Ask HN: Why Is Everything Declining? by uoaei on Saturday January 28, 2023 @04:50PM (#34562334)
People who wax philosophical almost entirely about what the inherent subjectivity of aesthetics means for our experience as subjects, individually and collectively.
Re:Ask HN: Why Is Everything Declining? by kelseyfrog on Saturday January 28, 2023 @07:34PM (#34563585)
This line of reasoning is unsound because it attempts to universalize particulars wrt aesthetics. Universalizing particulars is what Lacan would call psychotic. The antidote here is a good dose hysterics.
Re:Ask HN: Why Is Everything Declining? by __MatrixMan__ on Saturday January 28, 2023 @04:01PM (#34561811)
What should one do if they find that the aesthetic norms practiced by the people around them don't align with anyone's values?

Is there room in your clean, well architected, art-endowed society for protest? If not, what keeps the norms in-line with the (presumably drifting) values?

Re:Ask HN: Why Is Everything Declining? by kortilla on Saturday January 28, 2023 @04:17PM (#34561981)
>beautiful art

Wow, you just keep digging deeper. Pray tell, what makes some art beautiful and other art not?

Re:Ask HN: Why Is Everything Declining? by __MatrixMan__ on Saturday January 28, 2023 @03:56PM (#34561768)
I think we ought to distinguish between the case where the person has thought through their decision to wear pajamas in public and is doing it as an attempt to challenge existing norms, versus the case where they didn't even give it a thought.

Because if that's what they're doing, then I'm 100% with you. Hanging onto existing norms is just opting out of the conversation about what the norms should be.

I suspect, though, that gp is objecting to a different sort of opting-out--one where you're either blind or apathetic to the consequences of your actions.

I guess what I'm saying is, it depends on the pajamas.

Re:Ask HN: Why Is Everything Declining? by jodrellblank on Saturday January 28, 2023 @04:07PM (#34561889)
> blind or apathetic to the consequences of your actions.

People have asked in this thread about the consequences of wearing pajamas and it seems to be that self-styled art experts will be offended.

To quote comedian Steve Hughes, ok, be offended - nothing happens.

Re:Ask HN: Why Is Everything Declining? by meheleventyone on Saturday January 28, 2023 @04:15PM (#34561958)
But norms change because it becomes normal to do it which requires people do it without thinking about it. By definition.

If people only do subversive things intentionally nothing changes. That’s in fact what the conservative view wants, safe “change” that doesn’t actually matter. Which is why for example Iran is cracking down so hard on the recent protests because they desperately need for the norm not to change.

Re:Ask HN: Why Is Everything Declining? by __MatrixMan__ on Saturday January 28, 2023 @08:48PM (#34564051)
I feel like there's more middle ground than you're acknowledging.

Yes, people eventually start doing a thing because it's the new normal--but it doesn't happen spontaneously. Some emergent leader decides to wear pajamas to the office (or whatever) and then the barrier is lowered and others follow suit because the leader had a point and then eventually being comfortable in public is the new normal. But that emergent leader is required, no?

Somebody has to do it first.

I've been witnessing this in my neighborhood. Some apartment complex put up a fence and now the route to the grocery is long and circuitous because we can no longer cut through the apartment complex's parking lot. Some hero dismantled the fence to make a hole and now the whole neighborhood is reopening the hole when the complex repairs it. I'm happy to participate in the maintaining the new normal, but I wasn't the hero that set it up in the first place. I'm in that guy's debt.

Re:Ask HN: Why Is Everything Declining? by bheadmaster on Saturday January 28, 2023 @03:45PM (#34561648)
Some people not only think that that aestethics is entirely objective (which may or may not be true), but also think that their perception is somehow authoritative on the matter!

Their opinion is that everything they like is objectively beautiful, and everything they don't like is objectively ugly.

How narcissistic do those people have to be to hold themselves in such an unrealistically high regard?

Re:Ask HN: Why Is Everything Declining? by kortilla on Saturday January 28, 2023 @04:15PM (#34561952)
>Some people think that aesthetics is entirely subjective. This is the default view of Western liberal democracies, especially among people that haven’t really thought much about the topic.

Don’t do this. It’s a weaseling way to claim the person you are discussing things with isn’t thinking.

Do you think the following is fair?

Some people think that freedom of expression in appearance is unimportant. This is the default view of authoritarian societies, especially among people who have not really thought much about the topic.

Re:Ask HN: Why Is Everything Declining? by CJefferson on Saturday January 28, 2023 @04:55PM (#34562384)
You've made a massive leap here. Of course there is an argument that aesthetics aren't entirely subjective.

Are there any noteworthy philosopher who says (in effect, obviously not this exactly) people shouldn't go around in pyjamas?