News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Florida teachers could face felony for books in classroom... by isthisthingon99 on Saturday January 28, 2023 @11:07AM (#34558712)
It seems like they have the freedom to choose books so long as the child isn't exposed to sex and racism.
Re:Florida teachers could face felony for books in classroom... by retrac on Saturday January 28, 2023 @11:28AM (#34558909)
That might be reasonable for young children.

But in high school, some of the books we read were Nineteen-Eighty-Four (liberating power of sexuality is a theme), To Kill a Mockingbird (rape trial in the Jim Crow south), Huckleberry Finn (often considered racist in contemporary American society due to its frequent use of the n-word) and the Handmaid's Tale (rape and gender relations and racism).

I can't really imagine how literature, or society and history for that matter, can be taught without sex and racism coming up, and frequently.

Re:Florida teachers could face felony for books in classroom... by ttfkam on Saturday January 28, 2023 @11:43AM (#34559054)
And no "Watchmen", "Dune"… not even X-Men comics. Certainly not "Maus". No "Native Son", no "Farewell to Manzanar". No "The Good Earth". No "The Grapes of Wrath". No "Of Mice and Men". No "Invisible Man". No "Autobiography of Malcolm X". Absolutely none of Martin Luther King's speeches aside from "I Have a Dream".

Certainly not 99% of poetry.

Also would mean "Othello", "The Merchant of Venice", and all of the cross-dressing comedies like "Twelfth Night" are right out.

I completely agree with you that if this is allowed to stand, it would gut education irreparably. Critical thinking is already under fire; this would drop a nuke on it.

Re:Florida teachers could face felony for books in classroom... by isthisthingon99 on Saturday January 28, 2023 @03:56PM (#34561762)
Yes I agree, for young children. That's what I thought this was about.
Re:Florida teachers could face felony for books in classroom... by coffeefirst on Saturday January 28, 2023 @11:36AM (#34558996)
Given the books being targeted by this movement have included Maus and Toni Morrison, I don't see how its possible to take this in good faith.

Reasonable people can disagree about what's age appropriate. Threatening teachers with a felony charge is psychotic.

Re:Florida teachers could face felony for books in classroom... by sonotathrowaway on Saturday January 28, 2023 @01:02PM (#34559838)
It’s not in good faith, it’s just a sound bite they heard that can be used to justify not thinking about it any further.
Re:Florida teachers could face felony for books in classroom... by klyrs on Saturday January 28, 2023 @12:14PM (#34559354)
If a book only featuring white people isn't racist, then a book only featuring black people isn't racist. If a book ending with a prince living happily ever after with a princess isn't about sex, then a book ending with two princes living happily ever after isn't about sex. However, these are not the standards that Florida is applying.
Re:Florida teachers could face felony for books in classroom... by troad on Saturday January 28, 2023 @12:58PM (#34559805)
Can you point me towards some evidence of that? I’m not saying you’re wrong, I’m genuinely interested.
Re:Florida teachers could face felony for books in classroom... by spamuel on Saturday January 28, 2023 @01:23PM (#34560045)
The rule says books that are pornographic. This became an issue because teachers began putting books like "Genderqueer" in school libraries and classrooms, featuring explicit illustrations of apparently children engaging in things like fellatio on a dildo, anal sex with a strap-on, etc.

This isn't about Romeo and Juliet. Do you have a better way to describe those kinds of books? Or do you support having "Genderqueer" in elementary school libraries?

Re:Florida teachers could face felony for books in classroom... by xibo9 on Saturday January 28, 2023 @01:53PM (#34560350)
You repeatedly state these things as fact, and you provide zero evidence ANYWHERE in this discussion.

Are you simply here to divide and generate ragebait, or are you here to engage in serious discussion?

Re:Florida teachers could face felony for books in classroom... by spamuel on Saturday January 28, 2023 @01:54PM (#34560363)
Did you try googling "Genderqueer schools"? Maybe you're just not aware of this trend, and you think this is about Puritans trying to purge Charlotte's Web because the spider is naked.
Re:Florida teachers could face felony for books in classroom... by xrd on Saturday January 28, 2023 @02:23PM (#34560654)
I'm triggered by what you say here.

First, this is the most extreme example on that list. Lots of other literature is on there, do you support banning all of it, and jailing teachers that don't prevent a kid from reading it, because that is the real question.

Second, you say apparently, so it sounds like you haven't read it. Perhaps you don't want to, but have you talked to someone who actually has?

I've not read it, but I'm going to buy it. I went to the web page and saw the intention, which is to teach young adults (late teenagers) healthy sexual habits. If this book isn't provided to them, those kids are going to get it from alternative sources on the Internet. I mean porn. I don't mean to be "binary" (I'm happy with that pun) but it really is a choice between those two things.

By the way, that book isn't directed towards children as you assert. It's on the web site and clearly intended for young adults. Big difference.

When I read the book, interested in hearing my review?

Re:Florida teachers could face felony for books in classroom... by spamuel on Saturday January 28, 2023 @02:26PM (#34560705)
I've read it.

If it's not for children, why is it in school libraries? The problem is not that it exists. The problem is that it is being put in school libraries. If you read it you will likely see why. It literally has graphical depictions of children engaging in what would be considered hardcore pornography in any other context.

I can self-describe liquor as a "natural sleep aid for young adults", that doesn't change the fact that it is liquor and has no place in a high school vending machine.

Re:Florida teachers could face felony for books in classroom... by xrd on Saturday January 28, 2023 @02:37PM (#34560848)
I lived in Japan. They had vending machines that sell liquor and they trust kids not to buy it. It's not a perfect solution.

If a six year old kid walked up to check out that book, wouldn't the librarian stop them? I think the answer to that question speaks to whether you believe in "grooming" or not.

You really feel like this is hardcore pornography? The images I saw didn't suggest that at all. There are people that engage in sex like that, I'm sure you know. Do you feel like it is morally wrong to have sex like that which is described and is that why you are saying it is hardcore pornography?

I'll need reserving judgement on whether these are pictures of children engaging in sex. I would be very surprised if that's what is depicted. You are sure of that?

Re:Florida teachers could face felony for books in classroom... by spamuel on Saturday January 28, 2023 @03:19PM (#34561370)
At what age do you think it is inappropriate for a child to read a graphic novel about gay sex with several pictures of two other children engaged in oral and anal sex with a strap-on dildo?
Re:Florida teachers could face felony for books in classroom... by sagarm on Saturday January 28, 2023 @03:04PM (#34561182)
> the intention, which is to teach young adults (late teenagers) healthy sexual habits

Religious and conservative groups have been trying to cancel sex ed pretty consistently, so I suppose the opposition to this book is not surprising.

Re:Florida teachers could face felony for books in classroom... by spamuel on Saturday January 28, 2023 @04:25PM (#34562089)
Why is it being placed in elementary schools?
Re:Florida teachers could face felony for books in classroom... by xrd on Saturday January 28, 2023 @08:08PM (#34563848)
I'm genuinely interested in the answer to this. It is definitely found in an elementary school? I can see that it is on the banned list, but are you sure this book was actually found in an elementary school? Someone in a position of authority then needed to specifically order it, and that would be a dereliction of their duties if they did so, and that would prove the "grooming" assertion.

Is there documented proof that this was in an elementary school?

This feels like an important question. If it isn't found in elementary schools, then there simply is not a teacher or librarian out there attempting to put books in front of elementary kids. And, then this whole argument seems like virtue signaling for political gain.

Re:Florida teachers could face felony for books in classroom... by spamuel on Saturday January 28, 2023 @10:32PM (#34564599)
Did you Google it yet? This isn't an obscure issue.
Re:Florida teachers could face felony for books in classroom... by xrd on Sunday January 29, 2023 @07:35AM (#34567514)
Here is what I found:

https://wusfnews.wusf.usf.edu/education/2022-05-29/florida-d...

https://www.tampabay.com/news/education/2021/11/19/pinellas-...

Neither of these links say elementary school. One explicitly says high school.

I'm genuinely interested, is there an elementary school which had this book available for kids?

Re:Florida teachers could face felony for books in classroom... by isthisthingon99 on Saturday January 28, 2023 @03:57PM (#34561775)
I'm sure that the specifics and edge cases will get parties quite riled up. Still, I believe the general guideline of "don't expose young children to the themes of sex or racism" is reasonable.
Re:Florida teachers could face felony for books in classroom... by DangitBobby on Saturday January 28, 2023 @12:36PM (#34559579)
Is it really freedom if you get jail time for making a bad judgement call? You are free to assign "The Very Hungry Caterpillar" to your students!

Hope you didn't think "Little Bill" was appropriate.