Re:Why Companies Can't Quit Jack Welch's Much-Hated Employee...
by Nevermark on Friday January 27, 2023 @03:24PM
(#34551331)
Obviously, there will always be employees who are not working out that need to be let go, after reasonable efforts are made to accommodate and level up.
And serious economic conditions can require layoffs when company survival is at stake.
But, I think there is also a poorly recognized tension between two ideals. The first is where nobody who is performing well is ever let go. The where every employee a firm has, are the ones they would hire today.
Firms accumulate employees, but as the firms needs change, there is slow gap that opens between these two ideas. Many good employees, but not the ones we would hire today.
Hiring is not easy, but at least it is intentional.
Retention is the opposite of intentional. It is very much default.
I may be wrong, but I think mass layoffs, and harsh ranking systems, are often the blunt ways that this tension gets released.
--
What would a better system be? Employees would need to develop greater and greater adaptability and meta skills, in order to avoid becoming mismatched with sometimes glacial, sometimes fast moving, changes in the firms landscape.
Employees that drive change are most valuable. Next valuable are employees that adapt to changes, with their own initiative. Then employees that adapt well under direction.
Finally, good employees who are not so proactively adaptable may start out looking as valuable (to the company) as the others, but if they just remain good employees, their value is slowly seeping away.
The first step to solving this problem is for a firm to explicitly recognize that proactively leveraging change by EVERY individual employee, including the CEO, is the foundation of any long term job security.
The second step, is to recognize that competence and retention are not tied together, and to give employees who are no longer today's best fit very generous package to reflect they were successful employees. The speed of change has to mean some positive relationships are still shorter than they were.
A successful employee should feel that their stint was a success for themselves, in respect, compensation, and improvements to future opportunities, even as they leave.
And serious economic conditions can require layoffs when company survival is at stake.
But, I think there is also a poorly recognized tension between two ideals. The first is where nobody who is performing well is ever let go. The where every employee a firm has, are the ones they would hire today.
Firms accumulate employees, but as the firms needs change, there is slow gap that opens between these two ideas. Many good employees, but not the ones we would hire today.
Hiring is not easy, but at least it is intentional.
Retention is the opposite of intentional. It is very much default.
I may be wrong, but I think mass layoffs, and harsh ranking systems, are often the blunt ways that this tension gets released.
--
What would a better system be? Employees would need to develop greater and greater adaptability and meta skills, in order to avoid becoming mismatched with sometimes glacial, sometimes fast moving, changes in the firms landscape.
Employees that drive change are most valuable. Next valuable are employees that adapt to changes, with their own initiative. Then employees that adapt well under direction.
Finally, good employees who are not so proactively adaptable may start out looking as valuable (to the company) as the others, but if they just remain good employees, their value is slowly seeping away.
The first step to solving this problem is for a firm to explicitly recognize that proactively leveraging change by EVERY individual employee, including the CEO, is the foundation of any long term job security.
The second step, is to recognize that competence and retention are not tied together, and to give employees who are no longer today's best fit very generous package to reflect they were successful employees. The speed of change has to mean some positive relationships are still shorter than they were.
A successful employee should feel that their stint was a success for themselves, in respect, compensation, and improvements to future opportunities, even as they leave.