News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Natural language is the lazy user interface by haswell on Friday January 27, 2023 @02:07PM (#34550283)
For use cases that are well-suited to a conversational interface, that's great, and new AI advances will make chatbots more powerful than they've ever been.

But not every use case is a chatbot use case, and I think that's the key point of the article.

The sudden viability of a conversational interface that is good enough at having a fluid conversation to revolutionize the experience of that conversation does not suddenly make this interface the best fit for all use cases.

I still find it far more pleasant to browse to a page and see a list of clearly displayed options that I can absorb at a glance and get on to what I really need to accomplish in the moment.

Even a perfect conversationalist can't remove the extra friction involved in disclosing information in an efficient way.

Re:Natural language is the lazy user interface by ghaff on Friday January 27, 2023 @02:20PM (#34550475)
Even if someone designed an awesomely sophisticated air flight search engine that knew my usual preferences and could search for me and respond to follow-up prompts, I'd probably still want to see the information displayed on a page rather than read to me for the most part.
Re:Natural language is the lazy user interface by haswell on Friday January 27, 2023 @02:30PM (#34550606)
I think this might point to an opportunity to explore hybrid interfaces that allow you to just have a conversation while still having a visual representation of everything going on.

But still agree with the sentiment here. There are applications that I cannot imagine ever wanting to interact with via a bot.

Re:Natural language is the lazy user interface by dshah on Friday January 27, 2023 @02:50PM (#34550850)
This is how I've been thinking about it.

Hybrid interfaces that combine visual cues and output and natural language input.

Re:Natural language is the lazy user interface by ghaff on Friday January 27, 2023 @02:57PM (#34550958)
That's what I had in mind. Happy to talk to the computer but show me the results on a screen. If I'm typing in a freeform query, I'd generally just as soon say it instead. (Assuming I'm somewhere I can talk.)