Unlocking a device by apple has no bad incentives associated, at the very worst case someone else can use your owned device without access to any of your data, aka stealing. And that assumes that apple will corruptly open it for someone else which they have zero interest in and that just accounts for regular old stealing with a billion dollar company’s help?
We just have to trust their implementation, which is conveniently proprietary and unaccountable.
> And that assumes that apple will corruptly open it for someone else which they have zero interest in
Are you sure about that? They very publicly gave the Chinese government control over Chinese iCloud data a few years ago. That, and they've been part of PRISM for the better half of a decade now. When a company has a working relationship with multiple sovereign governments, I'm not sure you can strongman the "Apple will save us" argument.
This is also a problem with Google, Microsoft, Amazon, 95% of cell carriers, most cable companies and your laptop manufacturer (regardless of company). Apple knows you feel insecure about this, so they market their products/services to you with this in mind. News flash: does anyone really think the largest company in America (let alone the world) isn't in kahoots with the American government? Microsoft was. Google was. IBM was. And Apple is bigger than them all.
Encryption is great. Mixing it with snake oil isn't. People are correct to call out Apple's failures to protect their users in this conversation, because their track record isn't very benevolent.
I also have to trust Debian, as I can’t audit millions of lines of code.
You really have no choice but to trust your OS vendor. If you don’t, find another vendor.
Apple doesn't have accountability. It's not that nobody wants to prove them right, it's that their system has been deliberately designed so that no one can.
Funny misconception, that. You paid for it, but Apple controls it. You trust Apple to do the right thing, but you cannot prove that they do. You cannot hold them accountable for doing the right thing, either.
So, how can you trust it as an extension of your self? I understand your argument, but you've based it on a misconception if you think you're the ultimate user with the greatest authority over your device. Apple makes the rules, the only thing you do as a user is agree to play by them.