Re:Nostr: Notes and Other Stuff Transmitted by Relays
by jchw on Thursday January 26, 2023 @12:57PM
(#34535668)
This article equates "Child Porn" and "CSAM" with lolicon and shotacon, colloquially used to refer to drawings and other creative expressions, which is very clearly what they're avoiding mentioning. Of course, most people aware of fediverse politics already know about Pawoo and there is absolutely NO reason to speak about it in hushed tones, other than cowardice. Also, using the term "CSAM" to describe lolicon and shotacon is just intentional factual inaccuracy: the point of the term CSAM to specifically exclude content that doesn't directly involve the harm of a minor; that's what "abuse material" is meant to mean. That does not change the legal reality of the content, but it's bad to start out with the facts wrong because it paints the entire remainder of the discussion. Yes, it's complicated and uncomfortable, but let's not mince words.
When you run a Mastodon instance though, you don't actually need to distribute this content. In fact, you probably would at least ban proxying media for communities like Pawoo, and honestly, probably, any NSFW-oriented instance if you want to be safe.
I hate to break anyone's innocence, but this shit is literally everywhere on Twitter, and a lot of the rest of the Internet, too. Is it legal? Depends on your jurisdiction. Is it moral? ¯\_(ツ)_/¯. Only one thing's for sure: it's on your Internet.
Also, just an observation: either the author of this article is unaware, or feels as though it is not important to mention the other fun stuff going on with Mastodon, like the large presence of zoophiles. The internet is certainly a place to be.
When you run a Mastodon instance though, you don't actually need to distribute this content. In fact, you probably would at least ban proxying media for communities like Pawoo, and honestly, probably, any NSFW-oriented instance if you want to be safe.
I hate to break anyone's innocence, but this shit is literally everywhere on Twitter, and a lot of the rest of the Internet, too. Is it legal? Depends on your jurisdiction. Is it moral? ¯\_(ツ)_/¯. Only one thing's for sure: it's on your Internet.
Also, just an observation: either the author of this article is unaware, or feels as though it is not important to mention the other fun stuff going on with Mastodon, like the large presence of zoophiles. The internet is certainly a place to be.