News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Study reveals average age at conception for men vs. women... by mertd on Sunday January 22, 2023 @11:16PM (#34485403)
Somewhat grim, but this has to be disregarding the humans who never reach the reproductive age or the ones who cannot keep their offspring alive. So there is some survivorship bias baked into the methodology.
Re:Study reveals average age at conception for men vs. women... by tanbog5 on Monday January 23, 2023 @12:05AM (#34485704)
If I understand the method correctly, they are actually determining the age that the sample's parents generated dna material that went on to create them.

So everyone who has a parent is included - which is everyone who ever lived.

Re:Study reveals average age at conception for men vs. women... by asgraham on Monday January 23, 2023 @01:59AM (#34486253)
They can't possibly be working with genomes spanning the past 250k years--- the oldest known human remains are only estimated to be ~230k years old, and I doubt they have parent/child trios nicely spanning the intervening few hundred thousand years. So they have to be working on mutation rate inferences.

From a non-expert reading of the article, their pipeline is more like: modern human population genomes -> estimates of modern mutations' ages -> estimate of average historical parental ages.

The first estimation (genome -> mutation ages) was carried out in a prior study "GEVA" [1], and this paper's contribution seems to be estimating the average parental ages based on those previously estimated historical mutation rates.

I couldn't find any mention of using old DNA samples. The GEVA study pulls from two genome databases, TGP [2] and SGDP [3], both of which seem to be entirely modern genomes. I'm not an expert in the field, so maybe it's obvious to a population geneticist that these databases do include old genomes.

Given that they're only using modern (surviving) genomes, the critique of survivorship bias seems valid.

[1] https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6992231/

[2] https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4750478/

[3] https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5161557/

Re:Study reveals average age at conception for men vs. women... by wolverine876 on Monday January 23, 2023 @12:36AM (#34485847)
It frustrates me that people on HN, an intelligent crowd, draw conclusions without a serious basis. Why not ask,

'Is this study disregarding the humans who never reach the reproductive age or the ones who cannot keep their offspring alive? Is there is some survivorship bias baked into the methodology?'

You might find out - we might find out - rather than you guess wrong, never find out, and we all carry the error with us.

Re:Study reveals average age at conception for men vs. women... by MobiusHorizons on Monday January 23, 2023 @01:52AM (#34486223)
As I understand it, what the OP is saying is not something any study could ever control for without perfectly preserved DNA from a statistically significant sample of DNA from human populations going back to old generations. Any study that uses DNA collected from modern humans will weed out the DNA of humans whose descendants are not living today. Hence survivorship bias.
Re:Study reveals average age at conception for men vs. women... by wolverine876 on Monday January 23, 2023 @03:55AM (#34486796)
The problem is turning your 2 minute analysis into a conclusion instead of an informed question. The Internet is filled with such conclusions; another adds nothing.
Re:Study reveals average age at conception for men vs. women... by ejb999 on Monday January 23, 2023 @05:56AM (#34487406)
>>The Internet is filled with such conclusions; another adds nothing. reply

Problem is, the internet is also filled with studies that prove or disprove anything you want, best to be skeptical.

I personally don't put much credence into any studies that seriously thinks they can make any factual accurate statements about things that may or may not have happened 250,000 years ago. Science is never settled.

Re:Study reveals average age at conception for men vs. women... by usrusr on Monday January 23, 2023 @02:10AM (#34486304)
The study seems to look exclusively at the outcome in the contemporary gene pool. And not at archeological DNA samples, because then the x axis would be in years not in generations. There's nothing to compensate for or disregard, the study simply does not claim to describe anything it cannot (very indirectly) see.
Re:Study reveals average age at conception for men vs. women... by scajanus on Monday January 23, 2023 @04:19AM (#34486918)
If anything, more intelligent people might be more suspectible to these kind of errors -- assuming their intelligence applies and extends to fields they have little knowledge of. And also just enjoy intellectual speculation as such.

From the comments, it is pretty clear to me that people lack understanding of biology/modern computational genomics, and the models used and their limitations.

Re:Study reveals average age at conception for men vs. women... by james4k on Monday January 23, 2023 @03:19AM (#34486627)
And maternal mortality rates.
Re:Study reveals average age at conception for men vs. women... by AdrianB1 on Monday January 23, 2023 @08:15AM (#34488348)
By definition yes.

"Average age of people who gave birth include people who never give birth?" or "Is a selection bias to include only people who gave birth in the selection of people who gave birth" sound completely different if asked this way, right?