News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Do Large Language Models learn world models or just surfa... by klodolph on Sunday January 22, 2023 @01:53PM (#34480893)
Yes. I am worried that over the long term, models which are explainable or justifiable will be pushed aside by models which are nonexplainable and nonjustifiable, because the nonexplainable / nonjustifiable models are cheaper to get running and in the end we are all trapped inside a system that ruthlessly optimizes short-term costs.

I've only done a small amount of statistical work professionally, but I remember that it was basically a nightmare to try and collect the right data and use the right variables to get a useful inference. Other engineers on my team would try to improve the models by throwing more variables at them or increasing the number of parameters in the model and I was always pushing back on this. I felt a bit crazy pushing back on this--surely, using more variables and more parameters will make the model fit historical data more closely, and a model which fits historical data more closely will fit future data more closely, and a model which fits future data more closely will be more useful?

Explaining why this is wrong is really hard. I have deep respect for people who are able to explain the principles of statistics and statistical modeling.

Re:Do Large Language Models learn world models or just surfa... by thaumasiotes on Sunday January 22, 2023 @02:25PM (#34481308)
> I felt a bit crazy pushing back on this--surely, using more variables and more parameters will make the model fit historical data more closely, and a model which fits historical data more closely will fit future data more closely, and a model which fits future data more closely will be more useful?

> Explaining why this is wrong is really hard.

Seems straightforward. Points 1 and 3 are correct; point 2 is false.

Re:Do Large Language Models learn world models or just surfa... by klodolph on Monday January 23, 2023 @02:48AM (#34486465)
Points 1 and 2 are both wrong also.

Statistics is not intuitive.

Re:Do Large Language Models learn world models or just surfa... by thaumasiotes on Monday January 23, 2023 @05:49AM (#34487372)
Point 1 isn't wrong; it's correct. There's a reason the name for this problem is "overfitting".
Re:Do Large Language Models learn world models or just surfa... by klodolph on Monday January 23, 2023 @01:02PM (#34492486)
Yeah, it sounds like you’re assuming two things things here which are often (or usually) wrong:

1. No cross-validation, and

2. You have the ability to solve for additional parameters without losing accuracy.

Statistics is not intuitive.