I'm opposed to them having my search queries.
But they already did! It seems you're not opposed to them having you queries, but to them doing something that might actually be useful to you with such queries (as opposed to using them just for ads).
Don't get me wrong, I fully understand not wanting Google to know everything about you, but switching because of this new feature doesn't make much sense, since it doesn't actually change that, just exposes it.
The claim that you are replying to is not that they are getting the exact same information anyway, it's that they are still getting personal information and machines, not people, are seeing it and showing you ads/search results.
I also agree with this claim. I still understood the original post as "if they can read your e-mail, they know what you've been searching for anyway". This is simply not true.
They host my e-mail, I'm opposed to them having my search queries.