Re:San Francisco Falls into the Abyss
by CamperBob2 on Saturday January 21, 2023 @02:45PM
(#34469605)
He's talking specifically about the people who left, not the people who are still there.
Re:San Francisco Falls into the Abyss
by zeroonetwothree on Saturday January 21, 2023 @02:51PM
(#34469665)
No, he is speculating about the people that left based on the general distribution:
> But because the income distribution is such that the median income is greater than its simple arithmetic average, the median income of taxpayers who left San Francisco would probably have been around $250,000.
I'm sympathetic to the argument that there might be something unusual about the income distribution of the people who left San Francisco for various ski resort towns but pulling a very specific number like $250k out of the air is weird.
The silliest part is that it doesn't change the argument. $196k is a good income, $250k is better but not qualitatively different by any means.
It is not pulled out of thin air. It's Stanford/Hoover, if they have access to the mean they have access to the median, probably more fine grained data too.
You would think that, but the article text says otherwise:
> the median income of taxpayers who left San Francisco would probably have been around $250,000.
I am as puzzled as you, why not just calculate the median or email the people with the data and ask for it? Otherwise it feels like reaching for anything to embellish a partisan talking point.
Re:San Francisco Falls into the Abyss
by carbocation on Saturday January 21, 2023 @02:46PM
(#34469620)
The fact that the lower end of income is bounded—while the upper end is not—is true for both groups.
Indeed in SF average household income is $167k while median is $120k.