I believe that specific piece of software is already being investigated by the Government for anti-competitive, price fixing like behavior
It would require a unilateral cartel without meaningful supply outside of that agreement to actually fix prices.
That being said, this kind of behavior should be subdued as much as possible, within reason
A lot of this is geographical monopolies and actual liquid stock is often quite limited, so long as price is set at the margin and the managed property is on that margin they can elevate the price. This is easy enough to do as low rent options don’t stay on the market. Plus non-managed properties will benchmark themselves against the market which includes the managed properties allowing for price leadership.
There is a whole zoo of anti-competitive behavior strewn through business that is tolerated due to the immense amount of money that is made that is beneficial to governments who tax it and politicians who receive donations. I don’t know how to fix it, step 1 seems to be fix political corruption and that already seems impossible. Once something becomes corrupted it’s very difficult to un-corrupt it.
you are factually inaccurate there, for most US metropolitan areas on the East and West coasts. In particular, the San Francisco Bay Area for sustained decade+, had several hundred thousand more available jobs than available places to live.
source: professional Urban Planners in California
And those jobs in SF are likely to go remote in large part, as we've already seen a strong transition towards. It's not very economically efficient to make employment contingent on location, so I'm doubtful that will continue to be the baseline model for white collar work.
Home prices in the Bay Area are driven by local employment, yet I can take the same job now and move to Texas and buy a 300k house rather than 3 million. The amenities and culture will develop over time.
Doesn't seem to be a very favorable outlook from a fundamental perspective for BA RE prices to me
That's not to say that other cities don't have a similar mix, but those other cities are not home to the headquarters of highly-paid software folks who all compete for housing. Even Seattle folks priced out can possibly afford places way up north in Everett or down south in Tacoma, if one absolutely must have a house for whatever reason. Even cities that are a heinous commute to Silicon Valley (e.g. Santa Cruz) are still wildly expensive.
The proper metric would be "population entering peak home-buying & child-rearing years / (deaths + population entering senior homes + new home construction)". I'm pretty sure that metric is pretty bleak just looking at the U.S. population pyramid:
It's 1.1 housing unit to 1 household, same as it was in 2001. You can corroborate with FRED data for total households vs total housing units
Demographics were favorable for demand for the past few years due to millenials reaching homebuying age, but they quickly shift against demand over the next decade due to large elderly population passing on and lower population growth. Not even considering that homebuilding is at an all time high
But there is no housing shortage. There was a shortage of listings for a period of time, not a structural shortage. Number of housing units per household is same as it was 20 years ago. 1.1:1
[Different metric, but gives an idea] https://fred.stlouisfed.org/graph/?g=MvZv
Prices in previous tech hub areas will fall drastically if remote work sticks, so won't be a problem for future residents of SF/Bay/Seattle/Austin.