News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Make Up a Guy by blinding-streak on Saturday January 21, 2023 @08:15AM (#34466230)
Speaking of making a person.. at this startup I worked at years ago (before LinkedIn existed), it was a tiny shop and we were all maxed out time-wise. It was frustrating when we had to deal with incredibly persistent salespeople that wouldn't take no for an answer, and others that preyed on our time relentlessly for no apparent reason.

So as a joke we invented a fake employee with a fake name. I think his first name was Joe. We gave this person an email address and I made a voicemail recording for him.

When a time-waster was bugging us we'd tell them to contact Joe, "who is in charge of that" and provide the contact info. What started off as a joke ended up saving us a fuckton of time, effort, and hassle. For some reason Joe's incredibly upbeat and douchy sounding voicemail message was like manna from heaven for the relentless salespeople that refused to stop calling. It was an interesting social experiment of sorts. Joe was essentially a /dev/null bucket and never responded. But it worked.

This lasted for years and was really beneficial for us. Harder to pull off these days, but not impossible I imagine!

Re:Make Up a Guy by gilleain on Saturday January 21, 2023 @09:11AM (#34466516)
> Harder to pull off these days, but not impossible I imagine!

Chat-gpt + text-to-speech? Seems like AI-employees who 'handle' marketing calls would be quite possible.

Of course, then the marketers make their own AIs, and it will end up with the majority of phone calls being robots talking to robots.

Re:Make Up a Guy by Carioca on Saturday January 21, 2023 @09:14AM (#34466534)
It's all fun and games until the chat-responder inadvertently buys the product. And when/if you reveal the deception, the other company sues. In AI court, obviously, where it will be decided by an AI judge
Re:Make Up a Guy by scrollaway on Saturday January 21, 2023 @09:54AM (#34466798)
It's OK, the AI court is biased in favour of the AI, so the other company doesn't stand a chance :)
Re:Make Up a Guy by justinclift on Saturday January 21, 2023 @11:15PM (#34474201)
> the AI court is biased in favour of the AI

When both sides are using AI's for the call, that's not going to work. ;)

Re:Make Up a Guy by ghaff on Saturday January 21, 2023 @09:14AM (#34466537)
Somewhat inadvertently, as I largely stopped coming into the office well before COVID, I basically turned my work phone into a black hole. It's the number I give on contact forms but I haven't even known how to check voicemail for years.

I do have my cell phone in my internal contact info but the culture where I work is that pretty much no one makes a voice call to anyone out of the blue. And I'm very selective who else I give the number to.

Re:Make Up a Guy by dwighttk on Saturday January 21, 2023 @09:18AM (#34466568)
I still have a Google voice number for that. I occasionally have to remember to tell friends that it isn’t my real number… I think the voicemail message may even say that.
Re:Make Up a Guy by mensetmanusman on Saturday January 21, 2023 @09:18AM (#34466564)
Isn’t this wasn’t all support calls are now days?
Re:Make Up a Guy by paleotrope on Saturday January 21, 2023 @10:10AM (#34466903)
I wonder if this is going to change with time. Most people of a certain age remember a time when answering the phone and talking to the other person was a social more. This is the social courtesy that telemarketers and scammers have been using for years now.

But there's another way. Just hang up on them. I know it's considered hostile but it's just an outdated social more at this point.

Re:Make Up a Guy by travisjungroth on Saturday January 21, 2023 @11:15AM (#34467427)
I try to find this balance between recognizing the humanity of everyone I interact with and not allowing this respect to be an attack vector. Over time, I have shifted more towards ignoring salesman in front of a store, not replying to messages and hanging up on a call as being things I'm okay with doing. I don't always give courteous attention anymore. I'm fine with giving nothing ("ghosting" as the kids say) and only giving active rejection if it's really needed.

To your point, I think it will shift in a different way over time. Gen Z can't imagine hanging up on someone on the phone, they can't even imagine signaling to the other person they don't want to be on the call anymore (aka saying "goodbye"). But they don't end up on endless phone calls. They just never pick up the phone.

Have you ever been in young person's home when someone unexpectedly knocked at the door? It could be Tuesday afternoon and their whole body takes on this dread like they're realizing their life has suddenly turned into a slasher film.

I don't mean "kids these days are destroying society". They have other ways to connect than just showing up where someone lives. But I wouldn't start a business selling vacuum cleaners to the next generation of homemakers door-to-door.

Re:Make Up a Guy by chops on Saturday January 21, 2023 @11:52AM (#34467745)
The misanthrope in me has almost completely taken over when dealing with incoming sales calls, and I've almost completely abandoned the idea that anyone calling me to sell anything is worthy of the "humanity" label.

The moment it's clear they are selling something (it's usually pretty quick) the reply is "fuck off, never call this number again, and go fuck yourself" then I hang up and block the number. I only wish I could be vengeful in response and actually retaliate in some meaningful way to those that are particularly annoying or persistent.

The same applies to door-to-door sales people, moreso to door-to-door missionaries.

Re:Make Up a Guy by travisjungroth on Saturday January 21, 2023 @12:28PM (#34468100)
I’m not there yet but I get it. They’re taking something from you, your attention, and they’re trying to take more, your money. They hide behind social convention and you can’t retaliate in proportion.

Consider the return you’re getting by handing over your aggression to them. I don’t think you’re getting a good trade there. Saying “put me on your do not call list”, hanging up and blocking will have nearly the same benefit to your future but without the costs that the misanthrope brings.

Re:Make Up a Guy by sa46 on Sunday January 22, 2023 @01:46AM (#34475033)
You might like the book, Influence: The Psychology of Persuasion. I found the book helpful to reframe disengaging with sales folks from:

Before: "I'm acting uncharitably by not reciprocating attention."

After: "I recognize this person is attempting to influence me. I'm choosing not to engage."

Re:Make Up a Guy by travisjungroth on Monday January 23, 2023 @01:35AM (#34486153)
I read it when I was on a sales team. That period of my life may also have affected some of these beliefs...
Re:Make Up a Guy by vagrantJin on Saturday January 21, 2023 @11:28AM (#34467545)
> Just hang up on them

I prefer to leave them talking while I do more important things. Wasting their time is a better MO than anything.

Re:Make Up a Guy by bambax on Saturday January 21, 2023 @04:23PM (#34470686)
I never pick up the phone if the caller isn't already in my contacts. They can leave a message and I may call back, or not. But the risk of being caught into a stupid sales call for a new energy supplier or some such is just too great.
Re:Make Up a Guy by jbmsf on Sunday January 22, 2023 @03:40PM (#34481991)
I heard a fascinating idea somewhere... hang out while you are in mid-sentence.
Re:Make Up a Guy by bambax on Saturday January 21, 2023 @04:21PM (#34470674)
> before LinkedIn existed

It's surprisingly easy to make up a LinkedIn profile. I have one that has over 50 connections. Many sales people accept connections requests, and some non-sales people do as well. It just goes on from there.

I use him for looking up people without leaving a trace, and it's generally great fun to make him do posts on various topics.

I didn't put much effort in it though (for example, his photo is just a random stock photo, not anything AI-generated). I wonder how many virtual people exist on social networks.

Re:Make Up a Guy by cstross on Saturday January 21, 2023 @04:49PM (#34470955)
And then again, if you really hate your telesales callers, put them on hold with some hold music like this:

https://soundcloud.com/user-237714155/sales-call-abyss

Explanation of how/why they came up with it here: https://www.theregister.com/2016/04/29/it_helpdesk_creates_o...