[1] https://www.wtwco.com/en-US/Insights/2020/12/ceo-pay-landsca...
It looks to me like the problem is actually the opposite: these skills are so rare that an astronomical salary still won’t make it easy to find someone that can do the job well. Companies are paying these crazy amounts and yet still settling for relatively unskilled leaders, and they would get even worse if they paid even less. US ceos get paid more because the demand is higher. I have had the opportunity to work closely with a lot of leaders in industry, and have seen firsthand that only a tiny fraction are competent. A big portion of companies fail because they aren’t able to recruit anyone with strong leadership skills at any price.
If it was about competence, then the competent executives would've pushed out the incompetent ones in favor of competent replacements sourced from the general public. Instead, they do the precise opposite, favoring incompetent incumbents and fighting tooth and nail against competent replacements sourced from the general public. That fight is in vain: like any fight between the aristocracy and bourgeoisie, the latter has the actual skill and knowledge to win... only for their descendants to inherit their wealth and become the new aristocracy, against which a new bourgeoisie struggles - and rinse and repeat.
Put simply: it's the same Old Money v. New Money bullshit we've seen for as long as the concept of wealth has existed.
Only because the former keeps believing the justifications and rules dished out against them by the latter. Its not different than the religion in middle ages and how the aristocrats and priesthood dished out justifications and rules to maintain the order.
Otherwise the former has the power to change everything in the democratic apparatus.
My guess is the success rate would be more or less the same.
I've heard drug addicts say similar things about their next hit.
Think about this- they pay those high salaries, yet the best leaders they could get at this salary level think this private concert was a good idea. These people are still not high caliber leaders. Maybe they could have recruited better with a higher salary?
Ultimately, there is something wrong with the pipeline to leadership skills in our society, if these skills are that rare that they're nearly priceless. The world could really benefit from having a lot more skilled, strong, and empathetic leaders that know how to take responsibility and suffer hardship as needed to stick to their principles and goals.