They do.
The way it works is, developer builds and signs the APK and sends it to F-Droid. F-Droid then builds the app from source again, and if it gets the same APK, it publishes the one with the developer's signature.
On edit: What I meant by "unless something is checking" was that something independent had to be checking. Thought that was obvious.
I don't think there's any point in adding an independent auditing thing to this – is three pairs of (automated) eyes that better than two? But of course you can do that, the tooling for verifying it is open source.
(Of course, all of that doesn't work if the app doesn't support reproducible building, which is the majority of apps on F-Droid now – hence this post calling for a change)
I don't think that's a justification. It's them saying that that's how another party does it, then describing the problems with that approach in contrast what they're doing.
> unless something is actually checking that what's "reproduced" is the same as what the original developer originally produced.
As my sibling comment says, F-droid does verify it.
> And it is definitely better to trust only the developers than to trust both the developers AND the repo maintainers.
... Which this provides, by bringing us back to a point where you only have to trust the developer, and even then you have to trust them less because somebody else (F-droid) has verified that the binaries match the source code that they've provided.
"GOOGLE DOES IT"?????
... and reproducible builds don't solve much, at least not unless something is actually checking that what's "reproduced" is the same as what the original developer originally produced.
The big concern is updates, which have to be signed with the same key as the previous version. Reproducible builds do absolutely zilch for updates. And it is definitely better to trust only the developers than to trust both the developers AND the repo maintainers.
This is not to say that reproducible builds aren't goodness. All software should have reproducible builds. But come on.