News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google Announces 12K Layoffs: A difficult decision to set... by ketzu on Friday January 20, 2023 @09:45AM (#34453807)
Your argument seems to be that punishment only exists on an absolute scale (or relative to the overall population, not relative to the individual). Am I understanding it correctly?

If so, I heavily disagree and hold the opposite opinion: Punishment (and reward for that matter) are heavily individual. E.g., Only playing with a playstation for 30 mins a day might be a punishment for one kid, as they were playing 2~8h a day before, and a reward for another, as they haven't had access to that before. It is relativ to their life situation and independent of general playstation playtime.

But there are cases where punishment is somewhat absolute, mostly for severe infractions like violent crime. Even then, the degree to what a sentence might feel as a punishment might heavily diverge based on the person receiving it. E.g., a homeless person without a job might feel very different about going to prison for 5 years than a highly paid investment manager.

Re:Google Announces 12K Layoffs: A difficult decision to set... by js8 on Friday January 20, 2023 @10:34AM (#34454437)
Of course the punishment should be considered on absolute scale, based on typical (or perhaps even lowest status) people in the society, because it is ultimately administered by the society! Otherwise justice would lose any semblance of fairness.
Re:Google Announces 12K Layoffs: A difficult decision to set... by ketzu on Friday January 20, 2023 @12:48PM (#34456821)
Thank you for confirming I understood your argument correctly.