News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google Announces 12K Layoffs: A difficult decision to set... by bbarnett on Friday January 20, 2023 @07:34AM (#34452230)
This may shock you, but a company is not a person.

Further, there is zero wrong with a company's goal for profit. This is like water, or food, for a living organism, without profit the company will wither, and die.

A company does not "owe you" a job. You do work, they pay, and at any time you or they may walk away.

No one is owed a job.

So what's the beef here? You want some sort of corporate socialism?

Re:Google Announces 12K Layoffs: A difficult decision to set... by saidinesh5 on Friday January 20, 2023 @07:47AM (#34452360)
But that's the thing. So many highly skilled people, put to good use can multiply profits no? That's assuming that those 10k are not some part of their new stack ranking system.

How would you interpret massive layoffs when a company is not making losses?

To me, it looks like their existing projects aren't making the kind of money they want to make and they aren't interested in trying out more things that might give them a chance to make that kind of money.

Re:Google Announces 12K Layoffs: A difficult decision to set... by bbarnett on Friday January 20, 2023 @07:58AM (#34452482)
So many highly skilled people, put to good use can multiply profits no?

No. If true, merely having skilled people would immediately lead to a win for any startup.

How would you interpret massive layoffs when a company is not making losses?

I would only care to try, to spend the hundreds or thousands of hours to analyze google's actions (instead of guessing), if I cared to invest heavily it.

To the above I will add, a well run company does not wait to lose money, but manages finances ahead of the game.

Beyond that, share price is how google acquires, yes? So if share price plummets, acquisition capability plummets...

Re:Google Announces 12K Layoffs: A difficult decision to set... by saidinesh5 on Friday January 20, 2023 @08:16AM (#34452702)
Being put to good use is what multiplies profits imo. Don't get me wrong, i have seen with skilled/learned engineers, taking horrible technical decisions and causing their companies a lot of financial headaches. So I understand what you mean. Especially about "managing finances ahead of the game".

But at Google's scale (and profits..) it was a little weird to see(/not see?) no efforts of reorganization before all those layoffs.

Re:Google Announces 12K Layoffs: A difficult decision to set... by bnegreve on Friday January 20, 2023 @07:54AM (#34452441)
> This may shock you, but a company is not a person.

Corporations are legally treated like people, that is the point actually [1]. Given that they have similar rights, it is not absurd to expect they also behave like people.

[1] (from wikipedia) A corporation is an organization authorized by the state to act as a single entity (a legal entity recognized by private and public law "born out of statute"; a legal person in legal context) and recognized as such in law for certain purposes.

Re:Google Announces 12K Layoffs: A difficult decision to set... by prepend on Friday January 20, 2023 @08:03AM (#34452544)
Legal people aren’t people. This just means that rights given to people also apply to organizations and groups of people.

Otherwise the state could say “yes prepend, you have freedom of speech, but the church you belong to can’t say stuff.” Etc etc.

Re:Google Announces 12K Layoffs: A difficult decision to set... by bbarnett on Friday January 20, 2023 @08:04AM (#34452564)
No, corporations are not people, and legalities which apply in very specific circumstances and not relevant.

Do you, as a person, have a CTO by law? Have your value listed on a stock exchange? Can you be sold? Dissolved at the whim of the state?

A corporation is only a person in a very, very narrow set of conditions.

Re:Google Announces 12K Layoffs: A difficult decision to set... by bnegreve on Friday January 20, 2023 @08:05AM (#34452583)
Corporations are granted the right to sue me. That enough for me to expect that they show some level of human decency.

If they behave like psychopaths in a systematic way, I don't think they should be granted that right.

Re:Google Announces 12K Layoffs: A difficult decision to set... by smcl on Friday January 20, 2023 @07:57AM (#34452471)
Imagine being the guy saying "No one is owed a job" in the comments of a story announcing 12,000 people are being fired.