Re:PhD training is no longer fit for purpose – it needs refo...
by seydor on Friday January 20, 2023 @06:01AM
(#34451408)
Maybe in a few american Ivy-league it's a selection process. For most of the world it's "who has the patience and perseverance to go through that ancient hierarcy". In the past 15-20 years academic success has become increasingly based on social standing , and there are many ways to hack that one
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:PhD training is no longer fit for purpose – it needs refo...
by marginalia_nu on Friday January 20, 2023 @06:20AM
(#34451563)
Hasn't it sort of always been that way though? Social standing is a huge force multiplier in almost every human endeavor.
Re:PhD training is no longer fit for purpose – it needs refo...
by low_tech_love on Friday January 20, 2023 @06:59AM
(#34451866)
That is still a selection process… it’s just that the success profile is different. Even in Ivy league you can’t really say the ”smartest” ones are the most successful. Selection selects ”something”, and I don’t really know what to be honest.