News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:PhD training is no longer fit for purpose – it needs refo... by musicale on Friday January 20, 2023 @04:43AM (#34450831)
Is there really an army of suckers who are rushing to waste years of their lives on doctoral degrees and the associated lengthy, underpaid indentures? The statistics would seem to say so. Or perhaps this is the natural progression of the research (especially academic research) pyramid scheme?

Are we going to up the degree requirements for everything? High school to college diploma, bachelor's to master's, master's to doctorate, doctorate to ???

Re:PhD training is no longer fit for purpose – it needs refo... by blackbear_ on Friday January 20, 2023 @05:12AM (#34450996)
I'm one of those suckers and I'm glad I wasted years of my life being paid to study things I found interesting, on my own terms, without pointless meetings, impossible deadlines and unreasonable bosses, dropping projects and colleagues I did not like. Would do it again.
Re:PhD training is no longer fit for purpose – it needs refo... by neodypsis on Friday January 20, 2023 @04:50AM (#34450868)
A PhD degree in a relevant subject area (think STEM) can be a door-opener in industry, not just academia. Many interesting jobs are reserved for PhD holders, or at least, are more readily available for them.
Re:PhD training is no longer fit for purpose – it needs refo... by musicale on Friday January 20, 2023 @04:52AM (#34450884)
It can serve as a meal ticket in certain fields, yes. Should it? I'm not entirely sure. The opportunity cost is certainly high.

In less fortunate areas you can be consigned to a permanent adjunct or postdoctoral purgatory.

Re:PhD training is no longer fit for purpose – it needs refo... by neodypsis on Friday January 20, 2023 @05:04AM (#34450953)
Very true, the opportunity cost can be very high. There's always the risk of pursuing a wrong research path.

At some point I've considered that a second master's in a complementary field could make more sense than a PhD.

Re:PhD training is no longer fit for purpose – it needs refo... by DocTomoe on Friday January 20, 2023 @05:09AM (#34450977)
Beware, though, because in other fields - particularly in STEM - a PHD may actually lower your job prospects. "You're overqualified" gets old really fast if no one offers jobs that align with your proficiency level.
Re:PhD training is no longer fit for purpose – it needs refo... by neodypsis on Friday January 20, 2023 @05:15AM (#34451015)
Do you see this happening in CS? I've seen positions where they don't care if you have formal training or not, then why would being a PhD holder hinder your chances?
Re:PhD training is no longer fit for purpose – it needs refo... by DocTomoe on Friday January 20, 2023 @06:31AM (#34451653)
Channelling my inner HR drone here, but I've heard that all at different times from them when looking for talent:

Because why would you linger around in university if you can have a serious income ten years earlier? Obviously something must be "wrong" with you, something that would make you a complicated employee that just asks for creating trouble. Better hire a CS bachelor for a third of what you would ask (risking you'd run as soon as you get some offer more to your liking), not like we're doing any revolutionary bleeding-edge stuff anyways.

Re:PhD training is no longer fit for purpose – it needs refo... by dagw on Friday January 20, 2023 @04:56AM (#34450903)
I used to work for large civil engineering consultancy. They had lots of highly paid people with PhDs, hired because of their PhDs, doing work directly related to the thing they did their PhD in. So it obviously seems to work fine in some fields.
Re:PhD training is no longer fit for purpose – it needs refo... by Beldin on Friday January 20, 2023 @04:57AM (#34450913)
In plenty of non-USA countries, a PhD is basically a prerequisite to enter the higher echelons of government and the corporate world.

Not saying it should be like that, nor that it is completely impossible to advance in those countries without. It's more that there's a glass ceiling through which you'll have to break if you don't have a PhD. And I have talked with PhD students with such backgrounds who were quite clear on that. For a (to me) surprising number of them, an academic career was not the main goal at all (not necessarily completely ruled out, but not the original main goal).

Re:PhD training is no longer fit for purpose – it needs refo... by musicale on Friday January 20, 2023 @05:05AM (#34450959)
Ph.D. as expensive meal ticket would seem to support the need for reform.
Re:PhD training is no longer fit for purpose – it needs refo... by ryzvonusef on Friday January 20, 2023 @05:45AM (#34451235)
My BiL is doing a PhD in CS in in a minor uni in UK (scholarship from the uni + TA/RA -ship or whatever it's called).

He gets to be an indentured servant, but in the end hopefully he will have a piece of Paper from a 1st world country that will certify his already substantial CS skills. (also possibly, a Foreign nationality down the line, providing yet another piece of paper, a passport with respect)

In addition, my sister and nieces get to live in a good country, and I have been very impressed by their education, even a state school in UK is miles ahead of any private school we could afford here.

It's a trade he made, despite knowing he was being made a sucker, because the Upshot was going to be worth it in a decade's time. He was going to spend those years in academia (at a uni in my 3rd world country) anyways, why not get something for it?

----

I think that's how the assembly line will work in developed countries. As local citizens (like you and other commenters here) realize the two letters (Dr) are not worth the effort, uni will turn to academics from other countries, instead of actually reforming the system.

Re:PhD training is no longer fit for purpose – it needs refo... by michaelt on Friday January 20, 2023 @05:56AM (#34451350)
> Are we going to up the degree requirements for everything? High school to college diploma, bachelor's to master's, master's to doctorate, doctorate to ???

I suspect this has already happened.

In 1940, 25% of the population were high school graduates and 4% had college degrees.

Today, 30% of the population have college degrees, and ~4% of the population have PhD, MD, JD etc.

So a college degree doesn't indicate what it once did.

Re:PhD training is no longer fit for purpose – it needs refo... by snowpid on Friday January 20, 2023 @10:24AM (#34454316)
which country?
Re:PhD training is no longer fit for purpose – it needs refo... by seydor on Friday January 20, 2023 @07:35AM (#34452247)
Yes there is . Unemployment is a bitch. Look at the numbers of PhD in southern europe for an example
Re:PhD training is no longer fit for purpose – it needs refo... by matthewdgreen on Friday January 20, 2023 @09:22AM (#34453502)
Twenty years ago I left a miserable software development job for a PhD program where I got to think about interesting problems all day. Nothing in my life has ever been as much fun, even despite the lousy pay. Wish I could do it all over again.
Re:PhD training is no longer fit for purpose – it needs refo... by jimkoen on Monday January 23, 2023 @05:39AM (#34487334)
Amen. I always tell people that want to do a PhD that, if they want to torture themselves, I can recommend some really great clubs in Berlin for that. It's probably more healthy as well, psychologically speaking.