News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Your body wasn’t built to last: a lesson from human morta... by fragsworth on Monday January 09, 2012 @02:12PM (#3443814)
Evolutionary theory would also suggest that we have some mechanism to ensure our deaths. Longer lifespans cause fewer generations per time period, resulting in less adaptability as a species.
Re:Your body wasn’t built to last: a lesson from human morta... by JoachimSchipper on Monday January 09, 2012 @03:09PM (#3444034)
Why would evolution need that? If grandpa is badly adapted, he'll starve/get eaten/etc; no need for a built-in kill switch. In fact, if there were a kill switch getting rid of it would be highly adaptive, if only because you could be around to defend your great-grandchildren.

(Of course, we do die. But the explanation looks more like "growing and reproducing quicker beats longevity" than like "planned obsolescence".)

Re:Your body wasn’t built to last: a lesson from human morta... by JoeAltmaier on Monday January 09, 2012 @06:11PM (#3444777)
Grandpa wears out, yet competes for resources. Kill him off, more for the healthy youngsters. Certainly its selective, at the family/community level, choosing to keep more-efficient members.

I also think, making grandparents less mobile means they are around the campfire teaching the youngsters. It makes sense it would be selected for in a race of communicators.

Re:Your body wasn’t built to last: a lesson from human morta... by onemoreact on Monday January 09, 2012 @10:07PM (#3445447)
Mice and rabbits also age.
Re:Your body wasn’t built to last: a lesson from human morta... by JoeAltmaier on Tuesday January 10, 2012 @08:58AM (#3446933)
Sure. But rats quickly die when they become less mobile or arthritic.

Humans can live for decades beyond their most-productive years. Their has to be a Darwinist reason for this.

Re:Your body wasn’t built to last: a lesson from human morta... by onemoreact on Tuesday January 10, 2012 @09:45AM (#3447075)
The Darwinist reasoning behind rates of aging goes something like this. A adult mouse has a high chance of being killed in a random year (above 20%) a Parrot has a low chance (below 3%). Maintaining a body into old age has a cost that reduces reproductive capability in a given year and a benefit of increasing the number of years of reproductive capability. There are also minimums of capability in the wild where vision and mobility link to survival rates such that there are thresholds below which rates of survival dramatically decrease.

Thus, the number of healthy years in the wild relates to both the probability of an external death AND internal heath issues. For a mouse this suggests a minimum of internal maintenance for maximum reproduction where a parrot can make significant trade-offs in reproduction in order to live 10x as long and have more long term reproductive chances.

However, that's in the natural setting. A pet (mouse, cat, parrot) can live slightly longer in captivity by surviving pat the point where it can find food for it's self. If you look a human vision decline people are significantly less capable of surviving on their own before they lose reproductive capability. And in that "unnatural" old age it's not uncommon for various species to have increasing reproductive issues.

Re:Your body wasn’t built to last: a lesson from human morta... by ifearthenight on Tuesday January 10, 2012 @07:41AM (#3446720)
Thank you for not getting evolution theory backwards like the majority of journalists/scientists/people in general do.

We evolve because we don't die...we don't evolve so that we may live.

Re:Your body wasn’t built to last: a lesson from human morta... by reasonattlm on Monday January 09, 2012 @06:39PM (#3444891)
We age because the world changes:

http://www.fightaging.org/archives/2011/03/we-age-because-th...

But the degree to which aging is programmed - versus simply an unhappy stochastic decay due to diminishing selection pressures in later life - is a big and ongoing debate. Some species clearly have a lot of programming going on. For example, salmon age at a rate determined by the laziness of bears near to their particular rivers:

http://www.fightaging.org/archives/2007/12/bear-consumption-...

But there are equally good counter examples for many more species that suggest the situation is that evolution sets up to win the short race, front-loading as much as it can for early success, and then the selection pressure drops off after you had your shot at reproductive success. All that front-loading produces unpleasant later consequences as things fall apart - you're not set up for the long term.

The adaptive immune system is a good example of this - it's a system that could never run as evolved for an indefinite period of time. It's always going to crash and burn at some point, and that's somewhat a consequence of how it's evolved to run extremely effectively right out of the gate in early life:

http://www.fightaging.org/archives/2006/12/when-and-how-does...

For more reading on this topic, you might look into antagonistic pleiotropy - the premature optimization of the evolved world:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Antagonistic_pleiotropy_hypothe...

Re:Your body wasn’t built to last: a lesson from human morta... by TheEzEzz on Monday January 09, 2012 @03:13PM (#3444045)
This is a group selection argument. Why do you think the group selection pressure outweighs the selection pressure on individuals (which favors organisms who can produce the most offspring, and hence favors organisms who have long reproductive lives)?
Re:Your body wasn’t built to last: a lesson from human morta... by JoeAltmaier on Monday January 09, 2012 @06:15PM (#3444793)
Only in social creatures, who routinely share resources at some level. Like families or villages. It doesn't have to outweight anything; its just another pressure at work. So we settle at some mean reproductive interval and some lifespan, that optimizes for all the environmental factors in play.
Re:Your body wasn’t built to last: a lesson from human morta... by TheEzEzz on Monday January 09, 2012 @06:59PM (#3444954)
Imagine you're born into a tribe that has evolved to purposefully die, but you are a mutant that lives twice as long and has twice as many kids. What stops your genes from quickly spreading?

All known species die of old age. This includes species that are not social and do not share resources. Group selection can not be the mechanism at play here.

Re:Your body wasn’t built to last: a lesson from human morta... by jodrellblank on Tuesday January 10, 2012 @12:44AM (#3445861)
All known species die of old age.

Except, possibly, the immortal jellyfish. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Turritopsis_nutricula

Re:Your body wasn’t built to last: a lesson from human morta... by JoeAltmaier on Tuesday January 10, 2012 @08:53AM (#3446916)
All known species share their ecological niche with the rest of their members. They are also social to the extent that they court and reproduce.

In your example, what stops the genes from spreading is that the entire village dies of starvation or competition with other tribes that have younger, fitter members.

Its a matter of degree. Humans are social to a high degree, but possibly not as high as ants for instance. Ants eat members of the tribe that are injured, an extreme example of group-efficiency taking priority over the individual.

Re:Your body wasn’t built to last: a lesson from human morta... by swalsh on Monday January 09, 2012 @02:25PM (#3443862)
In a somewhat unrelated idea. I've always wondered what the prospect of immortality, or longer average lifespans means in a world with rapid technological change. I'm borrowing from the idea of future shock.

Young people on average, seem to be more acceptant of new technology, where older seem to be less acceptant. Additionally, from personal experience; I think younger people think about problems differently as well which leads to new developments. It makes me wonder, even if our capabilities to develop new technology are growing (Kurzweil's theory of Accelerating change) perhaps the age of both the general population, and the engineers will cause some level of impedance.

Along the same lines, if a growing population requires growing technological change. And my concept is correct, that age reduces technological evolution, is it possible that it also reduces our ability to adapt, and a natural population balance occurs?

Re:Your body wasn’t built to last: a lesson from human morta... by onemoreact on Monday January 09, 2012 @02:32PM (#3443894)
I think it depends on the form immortality takes. Old people are less adapt at technology for two main reasons they have less free time to experiment and it takes longer for them to learn. If immortality means you never retire but the average work week is 3 days and you have the brains of a 22 year old then I don't think there is going to be much of a problem. If everyone is stuck working 40+ hour weeks with a biological age of 70+ then adaptation is going to be an issue.
Re:Your body wasn’t built to last: a lesson from human morta... by JoeAltmaier on Monday January 09, 2012 @06:13PM (#3444783)
What if young people's much-lauded adaptablilty is simply, they haven't learned Anything yet so accept the 1st model they come across? That makes them appear adaptable, yet are no more adaptable than older members of society.

I think to change anything substantially, you have to wait for a complete turnover - everybody has to die off, before the seeds of change can take root.

Re:Your body wasn’t built to last: a lesson from human morta... by rsaarelm on Tuesday January 10, 2012 @04:05AM (#3446260)
If that would be the only thing going on, you wouldn't be seeing a drastic decline in the ability to memorize new information that isn't tied to complex models of the world, such as sequences of random numbers, in aging people.
Re:Your body wasn’t built to last: a lesson from human morta... by JoeAltmaier on Tuesday January 10, 2012 @08:55AM (#3446926)
That's taking it a step further. Aging people have other reasons for being unadaptive.
Re:Your body wasn’t built to last: a lesson from human morta... by onemoreact on Monday January 09, 2012 @10:06PM (#3445443)
Young people don't become less adaptable when educated. If anything learning new things fights cognitive decline it does not speed it up.
Re:Your body wasn’t built to last: a lesson from human morta... by JoeAltmaier on Tuesday January 10, 2012 @08:57AM (#3446929)
Again, cognitive decline in the aged is taking it a step further.

Young people (< 20yrs?) are purportedly more adaptable than older folks, say 20-50. I maintain they aren't really adaptive, they simply have more choices when they learn their first pattern. And they have many patterns to learn, which takes years, perpetuating the myth that they are adaptable.

Re:Your body wasn’t built to last: a lesson from human morta... by onemoreact on Tuesday January 10, 2012 @09:33AM (#3447034)
Teaching a 22 year old PHD student or a 22 year old collage dropout a brand new skill does not favor the dropout. However, there is a fair amount of research that link rates of learning with biological age. With critical time periods that favor specific types of skill acquisition with significant benefits. What's interesting is ~25 years old is one of those cut of periods AND education tends to end at about that age.

PS: There is also trade offs involved which probably provided evolutionary benefits to those cutoff ages.

Re:Your body wasn’t built to last: a lesson from human morta... by JoeAltmaier on Tuesday January 10, 2012 @03:29PM (#3448855)
Perhaps cause and effect are reversed. Measuring young people, many whom are college students shows they stop learning when they leave college - not surprising.
Re:Your body wasn’t built to last: a lesson from human morta... by onemoreact on Wednesday January 11, 2012 @09:46AM (#3451938)
Neuroscience researchers are a little more rigorous than your giving credit for.

When they want to test learning they find people that don't know something, teach it to them, and test them at all points in the process. They also don't limit themselves to a single type of skill and can measure improvement based on how much they improve over time to measure long term skills acquisition.

Re:Your body wasn’t built to last: a lesson from human morta... by JoeAltmaier on Wednesday January 11, 2012 @11:08AM (#3452273)
Hm. "Don't know something" is not a rigourous state at all. Associations are how we know something; older students have more of them.

Unless they limit themselves to reflex action or some such, it becomes impossible to separate previous learning of anything complex.

I think I give researchers plenty of credit. But they don't often have the time/resources to have many/any controls. When a remarkable correlation appears (like 'students stop learning about when they leave school') I call foul.

Re:Your body wasn’t built to last: a lesson from human morta... by toumhi on Monday January 09, 2012 @03:40PM (#3444145)
evolution is not about adaptability of a species, it's about adaptability of individuals (it's not a centralized decision taken for the well-being of a species, but rather a consequence of individuals having more chances to pass their genes than others. The lucky ones are more adaptive).

If you take 2 individuals and one dies sooner than the later, the alive one will have had more chances to pass his genes, so it's not adaptive to have mechanism to ensure our deaths.

Re:Your body wasn’t built to last: a lesson from human morta... by ams6110 on Monday January 09, 2012 @10:59PM (#3445596)
That's assuming that individuals reproduce throughout their lives, which is not the case. Reproduction typically stops before death by old age.
Re:Your body wasn’t built to last: a lesson from human morta... by Someone on Monday January 09, 2012 @05:06PM (#3444519)
I do not think ere is need to postulate a mechanism for death. I think death is a side effect of the evolutionary competition between keeping the current organism healthy and creating new organisms. One would want both, but lack of resources forces a 'choice'.

Apparently, it typically is better to create new organisms every now and then. That may just be energetically better or it may be because (in particular, sexual) reproduction allows for faster adaptation to changed circumstances

Re:Your body wasn’t built to last: a lesson from human morta... by VMG on Monday January 09, 2012 @02:22PM (#3443850)
Longer lifespans cause fewer generations per time period

Only if you assume the non-reproductive members are a net negative (grandparents becoming a burden)

Re:Your body wasn’t built to last: a lesson from human morta... by fragsworth on Monday January 09, 2012 @02:51PM (#3443965)
Actually no, it's a little more complex than that:

Regardless of reproductive lifespan, in a population that is in equilibrium (not increasing or decreasing significantly), the average number of (surviving and reproducing) children per individual is going to be 2. So supposing we could live to be 1000 years old, and still reproduce at that age, we'd have an average of 2 generations per 1000 years.

Re:Your body wasn’t built to last: a lesson from human morta... by Wilduck on Monday January 09, 2012 @04:03PM (#3444238)
But lifespan and reproductive lifespan are different. Suppose we could live to be 1000, but only reproduce from ages 15 to 65. Then the equilibrium number of years per generation would be right around 40.
Re:Your body wasn’t built to last: a lesson from human morta... by VMG on Monday January 09, 2012 @04:55PM (#3444475)
Why should genes strive for an equilibrium? Even humans for most of history tried to have as many offspring as possible.
Re:Your body wasn’t built to last: a lesson from human morta... by fragsworth on Monday January 09, 2012 @05:19PM (#3444578)
It has nothing to do with genes - every population eventually hits a maximum capacity, after which it normally remains in equilibrium.
Re:Your body wasn’t built to last: a lesson from human morta... by VMG on Tuesday January 10, 2012 @02:42AM (#3446088)
I don't think that is generally true. Historically the growth of human populations has been exponential.
Re:Your body wasn’t built to last: a lesson from human morta... by mrbgty on Monday January 09, 2012 @02:58PM (#3443983)
I'm curious. What backs up the idea that the average number of children per individual will be 2 regardless of reproductive lifespan?

It seems that I've seen a somewhat(?) common pattern among people who have young families and get divorced that often times have another family (+2 children) when they re-marry.

Re:Your body wasn’t built to last: a lesson from human morta... by jowiar on Monday January 09, 2012 @03:31PM (#3444105)
The definition of equilibrium. Every child has 2 parents. Thus in each reproduction, every parent creates on average half a child (sounds rather morbid). Thus for the population to remain in equilibrium, each person needs to reproduce, on average, twice.
Re:Your body wasn’t built to last: a lesson from human morta... by makmanalp on Monday January 09, 2012 @04:24PM (#3444323)
> Longer lifespans cause fewer generations per time period

This is not true though. It would be true assuming a constant population size or a single offspring. The number of children I have and the number of children my children have has nothing to do with how long we live.

Re:Your body wasn’t built to last: a lesson from human morta... by ajkessler on Monday January 09, 2012 @06:27PM (#3444843)
But, how long you live might affect how many children you have.

Think of it this way: if you knew you had a high probability of living to 80, you might decide to have fewer offspring so that you could dedicate your earnings to supporting yourself in your later years (children are very expensive after all).

Regardless of whether this hypothesis is true, clearly the number of years you live likely has some bearing on how many children you might choose to have.

Re:Your body wasn’t built to last: a lesson from human morta... by _Y_ on Tuesday January 10, 2012 @01:40PM (#3448290)
I doubt it. If evolution really needed death then why does an immortal jelly-fish (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Turritopsis_nutricula) exist? Granted their final life stage is a polyp which creates a new young medusa, but there theoretically could be a specimen that is 7 millions years old. Either way they wouldn't need to change for number of generations.
Re:Your body wasn’t built to last: a lesson from human morta... by celticjames on Monday January 09, 2012 @06:23PM (#3444824)
Food for thought: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Negligible_senescence

Not all animals are pre-programmed for an early death. I wonder if curve for these animals looks like the lightening bolt curve?

Re:Your body wasn’t built to last: a lesson from human morta... by reasonattlm on Monday January 09, 2012 @06:30PM (#3444862)
The interesting question is how you figure out those curves in a decent amount of time and cost. When you pull a lobster out of a wild population, how do you determine how old it is? Lobsters live way too long to take the sit and wait approach with a lab population, and to date there's no reliable way to determine lobster age. So that's still a real challenge, not least because there isn't all that much interest in lobster aging.

http://www.fightaging.org/archives/2007/06/ageless-animals-t...